Call for consultation over extra Bristol to Bath cycle path homes

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

CAMPAIGNERS claim that a strip of land next to the Bristol to Bath cyclepath is set to be sold off without proper consultation.

Developers Squarepeg want the land to build five "cycle houses" which would have direct access to the cyclepath.

The plan is part of a redevelopment scheme for 267 homes, offices and shopspace on the former Elizabeth Shaw chocolate factory site at Greenbank.

Cyclist Chris Hutt, 57, of Clifton, who raised his concerns about the provisional deal on his greenbristol blog, has written to the council to formally object and started a campaign website – www.keepthebankgreen.blogspot.com.

He said: "The land forms an intrinsic part of the green corridor of the railway path.

"There does not appear to have been any consultation on whether the land should be sold.

"The city council has apparently taken the view that it is not required to consult.

"This may be technically correct, but given the controversies that have arisen in relation to most previous attempts to develop elements of the railway path it would, I suggest, be prudent to consult before a final decision is taken."

Earlier this year campaign group Save The Cycle Path successfully petitioned the council to abandon its plans to convert the path into a bus route.

Founder member Steve Meek, 45, of Montpelier, said: "Our concern is this sets a dangerous precedent.

"The strip of land is quite small but the idea the council can sell it off to a developer almost in secret seems completely wrong.

"It will change that area fundamentally, and part of the complex will be seven storeys high.

"I'm sure it's nice for the developer to have extra land as it will make the properties more profitable but I fail to see how it's good for the area.

"It seems to be against the council's own policies on green spaces, and seems to suggest the planning application is a foregone conclusion."

Residents and cycle path users have criticised the potential loss of green space.

Fred Miller, 44, of Easton, said: "A piecemeal degradation of the quality of the railway path has been going on.

"Local residents have been helping to maintain this stretch of railway path with gardens, at the Ruce Road junction, fruit trees and oak trees, and bramble maintained around the trees, near the allotments.

"These features are all part of the local heritage, which are threatened by this development."

Gloria Moore, 66, of Whitehall, said: "Whatever we say, they're going to do it but I don't really like it. I don't like them taking away green spaces."

David Nugent, 61, of Eastville, said: "I use the cycle path quite a lot, so I would say I disagree with this. It's eating at the resource all the time.

"But there is a bit of nimbyism about this kind of thing."

A spokesman for the council said: "The developer of the chocolate factory is negotiating with the council, which is finalising an in-principle agreement to sell a small strip of land, so that some houses may be accessed by bikes from the cycle track.

"The agreement is subject to planning permission and the resolution of all legal issues.

"A planning application is due to be considered by the council so it would not be appropriate to comment further at this stage."

A spokesman for Squarepeg argued the company had been open about its plans for the site, adding that response to public consultation had been positive.

She said: "This is not a surprise, this has been in the public domain for quite some time. There is nothing underhand about this

"This particular piece of land is the gateway from the cycle path to the chocolate factory. It will have five cycle houses set four to seven metres back from the path.

"We're also planning to create a cycling hub, including a cafe.

"There will be sympathetic landscaping, we're not creating a stark urban landscape. Whatever we take out will be replaced."

11
Tweet this article
Report

11 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by green bristol blog, bristol

    Wednesday, September 10 2008, 7:04PM

    “Jane, the "grudge", as you put it, against the developer and architect is that they have been very economical with the truth.

    Their sketches of the "cycle" houses were so misleading that they've now had to hastily issue new sketches.

    They've played down the new tower blocks and flats that will loom over the Path, omitting them from sketches and focusing on just the houses.

    Now that people are learning the truth many are surprised at the scale of the development along the Railway Path.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Jane Greer, Whitehall

    Wednesday, September 10 2008, 5:47PM

    “Brian McCulloch I couldn't agree with you more. There's so much campaigning to be done about green spaces in Bristol. It seems to me that the amount of energy put into this development is out of proportion. I wonder if there's something else going on. I've read the blogs and it seems as if it's not all about the council, about consultation and the land. It would be fair enough if that was all it was about. But it looks as if there some personal grudge against the developers and architects. I think it's childish and petty.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Brian McCulloch, Totterdown

    Wednesday, September 10 2008, 5:14PM

    “I wish this project well and I'm a keen, active and green-leaning cyclist. I¿ve just celebrated 15 years membership of the CTC and am a long standing member of Sustrans and can¿t see what all the fuss is about. This is an urban stretch of the path which would benefit immensely from an imaginative reworking of the old factory site. Turning an aspect of the development to face the cycle path is a great idea. You only need to look at how lively, popular and safe many European cycle paths are when homes and businesses border their fringes. I live close to the PaintWorks site in Totterdown and this is a thoroughly revitalised site following a similar scheme. If it had the advantage of a cycle path along its length it would have been even better. Let¿s be honest some of the recent safety concerns on the urban stretches of the cycle path are also due to its 'back passage' atmosphere. Why is everyone fixating on this site when we could be turning our attention to the challenges at some of the more 'down at heel' and risky stretches such as the approach to Barton Hill? I worry that an imaginative cycle-friendly re-development might get bankrupted because of some NIMBY attitudes.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Sian Fish, Warmley, Bristol

    Wednesday, September 10 2008, 4:47PM

    “Unfortunately it looks like the whole of Bristol's Green Belt and green spaces are under threat by house buiulders. From one side of the city across to the other more faceless new houses are cropping up in areas where there was once green spaces for the community to enjoy.

    Is the price of progress really worth what we're losing, and is building small box houses on fields really progress?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by ChrisB, Easton

    Wednesday, September 10 2008, 4:04PM

    “Are the campaigners basing their campaign on the latest information? The latest plans for the cycle houses on the Squarepeg website differ from the 3D image of them in their newsletter. The latest plans are at http://www.greenbankchocolatefactory.co.uk/cycle%2Dhouses/

    They show that planting will be replaced in front of the cycle houses, all of which will be between 4m and 7m back from the cycle path, much further back than is usual in street terraces.

    This distance varies along the length of the housing but does not fall below 4m. The houses will stand behind the wide verges but with ¿bridge access¿ on to the edge of the path for occupants.

    Re the 7 storey building: has the campaign forgotten that some of the original factory buildings are pretty tall?

    I hope this doesn't turn into another Castle Park, where in my opinion a group of dark greens has scuppered a good project.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article