Tesco deal could finance Bristol City's new stadium

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

A new supermarket at Ashton Gate has emerged as a key link in the funding of Bristol City FC's plans for a new 30,000-seater stadium.

The Bristol Evening Post can reveal Tesco is keen to buy the ground if plans for a new stadium at Ashton Vale go ahead.

But sources within the city council say that some officials and politicians are against a new store because they are worried about the impact on local shops and traders.

It was originally expected that the Ashton Gate site would be used to build new homes.

But the recession means that the amount of money generated by a homes scheme would not be enough to help fund a new stadium for the club.

Building homes at the ground would generate up to £5 million but selling the site to a supermarket chain could fetch an estimated £20m.

Former Lord Mayor Peter Abraham has warned that the city council must not drag its heels over making sure the new stadium is built.

He said: "The land value has to be maximised in order to get the money and funding for the new ground.

"It's pretty clear that a superstore, which would be in an ideal location, would provide the honeypot to make sure the new stadium happens.

"A superstore would help to regenerate the area, some aspects of which are looking very tired."

The football club is keen to go ahead with its new stadium plans as soon as possible – not least because a new home for the Robins could also provide a venue for World Cup games if the Football Association wins its bid to host the tournament in England in 2018.

It has been estimated by the city councilthat hosting World Cup games would generate up to £100 million for the local economy.

A purpose-built stadium would also help to give a lift to the city's prestige on the national and international stage.

In a statement issued last night, a club spokesman said: "Bristol City Football Club can confirm it is in discussions with Tesco Stores over the future of Ashton Gate. The aim is to ensure the club achieves maximum value for the site, whilst also boosting the economic well-being of South Bristol.

"All the monies received from the sale of Ashton Gate will go towards the development of the new regional stadium, which will be the home of Bristol City Football Club. Both Ashton Gate and Ashton Vale will be one of the biggest developments seen in Bristol for many years.

"The new stadium will give the region a huge economic boost as well as enabling Bristol to bid to be a host city for the 2018 World Cup."

John Savage, chairman of Business West, said: "Of course, I think a new stadium would be a fantastic piece of the jigsaw in Bristol.

"But I am also conscious of the sensitivities of building a supermarket on this site."

Another planning issue is the close proximity of the Sainsbury's store in Winterstoke Road.

Under planning policies, the city council must take into account the nearness of other supermarkets.

The area is also served by Asda in East Street, Aldi in North Street and Lidl stores in Sheene Road and Philip Street, off East Street.

The city council objected to Sainsbury's building a store on the former UBM site but the supermarket chain won permission after a public inquiry.

Sainsbury's also won the day when the company was allowed to turn its former Cargo Club opposite the ITV West studios into a supermarket, despite an outcry from traders and residents in Sandy Park.

A public inquiry could be held if planning permission for a new Tesco at Ashton Gate was turned down.

But such a decision could ruin any chances of putting Bristol on the football map by hosting World Cup games. The FA is keen to support Bristol FC's plans for a new ground because in order to win the 2018 bid, it must demonstrate that games can be held in all regions of the country and not concentrated in London and Manchester.

A new stadium in Bristol would offer the only chance of a decent venue in the whole of the South West.

The leaders of the three main parties on the city council reserved judgement on the prospect of a new supermarket when approached by the Post yesterday.

Council leader Barbara Janke said: "The Liberal Democrat administration welcomes the prospect for a new football stadium, particularly one that can be used for World Cup matches.

"Any planning application, when it is received, will have to be judged on its merits in the light of the council's planning policies."

Labour leader Helen Holland said: "We are hugely supportive of the club's ambitious plans for a new stadium and for Bristol to be part of the World Cup bid.

"We want it to happen and what happens on the existing Ashton Gate site is fundamental to the development of the new stadium.

"But the planning process must be adhered to and residents need to be consulted and the impact on other retailers assessed."

Tory leader Councillor Richard Eddy said: "The idea of a new stadium is tremendously exciting and I expect to see the council working with the club to realise their ambitions.

"But any development options for the existing ground must accord with the council's planning and retail policies and not have a detrimental impact on the community."

Ashton Gate, now a 21,500-seat stadium, became the permanent home of Bristol City in 1904.

In the past, plans were considered for expansion work to be carried out at Ashton Gate. There were also proposals to build a new 36,000-seat stadium at Hengrove Park. This was turned down in a local referendum in December 2000.

In 2002, the council was looking at possible sites for a new 40,000-seat stadium which would house both City, Rovers and Bristol Rugby, but these plans were scrapped and it is widely believed that a joint stadium would not have been welcomed by the majority of supporters from all clubs.

Ashton Gate's current capacity is an average size for Championship grounds, however in November 2007 the club announced plans to relocate to a new 30,000 capacity stadium in Ashton Vale with the option of expanding to 42,000 should it be considered for World Cup football in 2018.

As well as football, Ashton Gate has played host to many big music concerts in recent years, including those of Rod Stewart, Bryan Adams, Elton John, Neil Diamond, The Who, Ronan Keating, Meat Loaf and Bon Jovi.

Bristol City came within a whisker of winning promotion to the Premiership almost exactly a year ago but were beaten by Hull City in a play-off final at Wembley.

This year, the club finished tenth in the Coca-Cola Championship.

Council spokesman Simon Caplan said: "We are looking forward to receiving the club's planning application and its proposals for a new stadium and any associated development.

"However, as readers will appreciate, planning is a legal process and it would be inappropriate for us to comment on what might be contained in any application at this stage.

"We are keen not to prejudge any discussion or decision about a detailed scheme at this time.

"When any applications are received we will give them our careful consideration and work positively with the club to achieve a development that is appropriate and brings social, economic and environmental benefits to the city."

No one from Tesco was available for comment.

59
Tweet this article
Report

59 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by mike, withywood

    Friday, August 14 2009, 7:44PM

    “good day i have been a trader in north st for 6 years.i enjoy the community spirit that i have not felt in any other area i have worked in,the customers that come to my shop appriciate the efforts we put in to giving them the best service we can.we are a small shop with only five members of staff.i have been told that our customers loyalty will not weaver with the inevitable opening of a new tesco superstore,lucky me,but wot about the other shops if one starts to suffer and closes more will follow suit until we are surrounded by graffiti covered shutters and borded up shops,who would want to come to a street like that.People keep mentioning about having a stadium fit for the world cup,england have not hosted the world cup for 43 years,there are no guarentees we will host the 2018 world cup and i do not think one more stadium in bristol will change that.the world cup tournement last for 4 weeks and yes it will create revenue for this country but will it generate enough to last another 40 years till we are up for the next one.north st was a backwater for many years and now it has been turned around into a thriving community once again way risk destroying it with yet another unneccesary supermarket.the house valus in this area are still good value even in a recession property is holding its value,why risk ruining it all for one more supermarket.sorry about the spelling but debates are not within my comfort zone.Mike”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by liz, cash cow bristol

    Saturday, June 06 2009, 10:31AM

    “Hang on, isn't Ashton Vale green belt flood plain which soaks away water that would flood bristol? Building here was a not-recommended option in the regional space strategy. The Council blamed the housing proposal on central government pressure. So if this pressure for housing on green belt is gone why are the council still wanting to build here?

    And what happened to the plan to build a stadium next to temple meads? The preparation of that site cost us £30m. Seems like a better location for a football stadium/ concert venue. Better access etc.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Richard, KnowleDear last bbristolian

    Sunday, May 31 2009, 9:44PM

    “Dear last Bristolian
    You state there is no dereliction around the city ground. Have you seen the empty pubs? ship and castle,wedlocks
    and unigate dairy, manor tyres plus the awful state of some of the housing in ashton rd.
    As the last Bristolian you should get about your city a bit more.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by eve, ashton

    Thursday, May 28 2009, 8:24AM

    “it seems like deals are already done . planning permits just seem to be a bit of paper that wont stop either party.
    there are already two tesco's in the area why would we need a third? north st shops are already struggling and many more closed already (duckmoor road shops ) it will lose the community that has been there for years . i had a shop and the supermarkets force the little people out”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Sarah, Bristol

    Thursday, May 28 2009, 8:06AM

    “You are missing the point. Healthy competition is good, yes! But completely saturating the market with Tesco stores isn't healthy competition!!! Yes, there are already supermarkets in the area, but they have been there for years, and there is only one of each! ONE Aldi. ONE Sainsburys. ONE Asda and ONE Lidl. All offering a range of prices. And we also have North Street local shops which are still very busy and used by the community. Then we get to Tesco! There is a Tesco in Totterdown, West Street and North Street! All within a couple of miles of eachother, if that! Add another main supermarket and they will have swamped the whole area! Thats not choice, that's force! We may need the stadium, granted, but it will be in a lifeless city that has lost all sense of community spirit and replaced it with Tesco stores! Every little helps, but too much is a disaster!!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Wayner, Bradley Stoke

    Thursday, May 28 2009, 1:16AM

    “Surely competition is good for the local economy!! With Sainsbury's and Tesco so close ( and Adsa I suppose) it will drive prices down for local residents or at least give them a choice?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Paul wilson, Brentford

    Wednesday, May 27 2009, 11:20PM

    “If any of you have a chance to come to Brentford soon, then go to the High Street, apart from a newsagents, a curry house and one or two small, and dodgy grocery shops the rest of the street is dead.
    Less than 20 years ago Brentford High street was the busiest shopping area in West London, so what has happened, well building a shopping centre in Hounslow didn't help, but more importantly the GIANT Tesco, which claims it is in Osterley, killed most of the shops here, then of course the other GIANT tesco in Isleworth put the sqeeze on a bit more, and then finally we have been surrounded by the Tesco Expresses. To put it bluntly the only "new" shops to open around here are Tesco's.
    As for job creation, if you want a part time job, probably unsocial hours, all on a basic wage, then yes, they provide jobs.
    Whats worse is that this year alone four pubs in Brentford have closed, as their landlords say, "How can we compete with Tesco's?"

    Its about time they were stopped in their desire to own all the shops in this once great country”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Richard Lane, Knowle

    Wednesday, May 27 2009, 10:31PM

    “It really is sad hearing supporters of Bristol Rovers trying to belittle these plans when in reality they are the only club that has left Bristol, proposed two stadiums outside Bristol, Proposed to play matches again outside Bristol and formed a local political party opposed to the city ouncil in local elections.
    Get over it, appart from being formed a long time ago what have you really ever achieved? Okay you managed to rob the rugby club of it's long standing home and now they are tennants in their own house, you should be so proud of your old club.
    This new stadium is in Bristol (have a look at the boundaries if you are capable) but if it were in north somerset BCFC wouldn't have let down or decried the city of it's name as much as some others have.
    As for trying to get one upmanship by refering to names and year of formation they should look at their short history in the football league
    where they didn't join until 1920 and changed their name twice before this.
    Pot and kettle spring to mind.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Annette Hennessy, Portishead

    Wednesday, May 27 2009, 9:57PM

    “To Ed in Long Ashton, I am well aware that North Somerset Council is based in Weston and Somerset Council in Taunton. However, I was born and bred in Portishead, Somerset and nothing can change that. By the way, Weston-super-Mare's postal code is also BS for Bristol but nobody says they come from Weston, Bristol!! The neighbouring counties may seem irrelevant to other commenters but as the proposal for the new stadium falls within the Urban Extension Plan, it is of interest to all.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by alex phillips, north st

    Wednesday, May 27 2009, 7:43PM

    “I hate the company -they are hell bent on world domination. They use their bullying tactics to ride over local opinion and communities. Looking forward to the day they become extinct like the dinosaur they've become. Not before they've done their worst-and the shutters fall on North St and every High St as they pursue their insatiable and vindictive thirst for all things retail.
    The stadium will be built without selling your soul to the voracious animal Tesco.
    This retail giant is well documented for its sharp practices of tax-evasion and their abuses of buying power,selling power and continual abuse and exploitation of the planning system.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters