Sikh priest wins legal victory in wage claim dispute

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
Profile image for The Post

The Post

A SIKH priest paid £50-a-week through voluntary donations by the faithful has won a victory in his fight to prove he was a worker entitled to the national minimum wage.

Tejinder Singh, who served as Granthi, or priest, at Bristol's Sikh Gurdwara in Eastville for seven years until 2009, faces claims from the temple's elders that it flies in the face of Sikh scripture for him to be treated as a worker or employee under minimum wage legislation.

But a top judge has now ruled he can renew his case against the temple's managers before an employment tribunal after pointing out that he had to be available to worshippers for a fixed number of hours every day and was given free accommodation.

The temple's management committee argued that the £50 Mr Singh was given weekly from donations, as well as extra cash from worshippers for performing prayers and blessings, were purely voluntary in nature and did not make him a worker.

No tax or national insurance were deducted from the donations and the temple's management insisted that, to treat him as a worker, would conflict with religious principles of "voluntarism and a traditional interpretation and application of the Sikh scriptures".

As a religious office bearer, the management committee argued Mr Singh had agreed to give voluntary service and to "work without remuneration or any other personal gain".

But, ruling in Mr Singh's favour, Mr Justice Beatson said yesterday that, a Bristol employment tribunal that dismissed Mr Singh's claim last year had "fallen into error" when it decided that he did not fit the definition of a worker under the National Minimum Wage Act 1998.

"Arrangements between a church and its ministers should not lightly be taken as intended to have no legal effect," he told the Employment Appeal Tribunal.

The judge ordered a full re-hearing of his case by the same tribunal on a date to be set.

3
Tweet this article
Report

3 Comments

  • Profile image for manni4u

    by manni4u

    Wednesday, February 22 2012, 10:40AM

    “We are taught to work selflessly and voluntarily in serving Guru Ji. I personally wudnt think of it as a paid job but more of duty. Agreed, that some granthi's don't get what they deserve and some commitee members don't treat them well. For that all I can say is if one has immense faith in God then all difficult obstacles are crossed.”

  • Profile image for AmanpritSingh

    by AmanpritSingh

    Tuesday, February 21 2012, 11:10PM

    “Gurdwara Granthis should be paid well in UK, especially seeing as how the majority of them are treated badly by the committees. Many of them also are family people and being a Granthi is a full time job. Sure, the fact that they get accommodation by the Gurdwaras should be taken into account when they are given a salary. However, it should be fair. Gurdwaras do make so much money and some committee members also take salaries themselves for their services, which is nowhere near the amount of service that a typical Granthi does.”

  • Profile image for bonnet0uk

    by bonnet0uk

    Tuesday, February 21 2012, 6:03PM

    “Ermm, there are no 'priests' in Sikhism, there are only readers and the Sri Guru Granth Sahib can be read aloud by any Sikh. This appears to smack in the face of Sikhism.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters