Residents object to Bristol hospital heli-pad plan

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, November 04, 2008
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

People living in Kingsdown have objected to proposals for helicopters on lifesaving missions to land on the roof of the Bristol Royal Infirmary.

Plans for a £3-million landing pad on the roof of the Queen's building were announced in September to enable air ambulances to transport sick children and patients with serious heart problems to the hospital.

But Kingsdown residents have written to the council raising concerns about the impact of noise and vibration as flights make their way over their homes.

In response to the planning application, 16 comments have been made, either raising concerns or objecting to the proposed landing site.

The Kingsdown Conservation Group stopped short of objecting to the scheme after a public meeting where some of their concerns were dealt with, but did ask that a condition was set to prevent night flights and that work was carried out to make the appearance of the pad "less oppressive".

The biggest concern raised by people living in the area was that the noise and vibration of helicopters flying overhead would be unacceptable in a conservation area.

Residents also suggested the noise impact survey that had been carried out had not gone into enough depth.

Among the complaints was one from resident Christine Paz, who said: "I strongly object to this application and have difficulty believing that such a thing could possibly be granted in this location.

"Kingsdown is a residential area made up of many grade I and II listed buildings. The noise would be of an unacceptable level as would the associated vibration that comes with these aircraft."

Currently the only provision for helicopters to land in the Bristol area is at Frenchay Hospital, but plans are also in place for a heli-pad at the new Southmead site when it opens.

But University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust (UHBristol) is a regional specialist for heart treatment and caring for children, so a heli-pad is needed so the sickest patients can be transported to the site quickly.

The helicopter pad will enable air ambulances to fly patients for treatment at the new Bristol Heart Institute which is due to open in May and some of the sickest babies and youngsters to the Children's Hospital.

Aircraft will land on top of the BRI and patients will be transferred to the relevant department for their care by a dedicated lift, which is also included in the plans.

Danny Hopkins, of Great Western Air Ambulance, said Kingsdown residents should not be affected by the helicopter landing at the BRI.

"I think they are basing their views on the police helicopter, which hovers around", he said.

"This helicopter is one of the quietest in the country and will not be approaching or leaving the hospital via Kingsdown – they won't even know it is there.

"It takes two minutes to land and two minutes to leave and will access the pad from the city.

"There are facilities at the BRI and children's that are only available at the hospital, and potentially, putting someone in an ambulance and transferring 15 minutes by road could be a great risk to the patient. It could be the difference between survival or otherwise."

On average, the helicopter flies out to between two and four missions a day, five days a week, and so far has transported 20 patients to hospital by air a month, generally landing at Frenchay.

Andy Headdon, strategic development programme director at UHBristol, said computer simulation had been used to test the noise impact.The nearest residential house is 150 metres away and the helicopter pad is as far away as it can be.

"We have agreed with the operator that there will be a flight path that doesn't go over the residential area."

Bristol City Council planners have recommended the heli-pad should go ahead and a final decision is due to be made at a meeting tomorrow.

39
Tweet this article
Report

39 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by David Vestermark, kingsdown parade

    Saturday, April 18 2009, 3:42PM

    “if i get woken up because someone is being flown over because of medical needs that's fine because one day it might be some one i know who needs it. stop being so selfish all you people complaining about it, it's not like they are building a comercial airport on top of the BRI. you people make me sick”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Ailsa, Kingsdown

    Thursday, November 06 2008, 2:54PM

    “As a resident of Kingsdown with two young children (and living in a Grade II listed building incidentally), I would like to say that I have no concerns or objections whatsoever to the proposed helipad on he BRI, and would in fact welcome it. Residents of Kingsdown are well used to police helicopters in the vicinity and neither I nor my children are woken or disturbed by the noise, despite not having double glazing. We live in a central location in the city, not a remote country village. It is naive to expect total peace and quiet, and it is both selfish and ridiculous to object to something that will be saving lives and helping people. I can only assume that Peter does not have children himself or he would not have this point of view. One suggestion Peter, please buy some curtains or blinds for your bedroom and bathroom, if not only for your own sake, but for that of other Kingsdown residents whose view YOU may be spoiling!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Alex, Bristol

    Wednesday, November 05 2008, 8:45PM

    “I do not think there will be a helicopter every ten minutes Peter.

    Just for emergencies, it's not for you to decide what is aand what is not valid.

    I think the price of flying the copter will dictate how often it is used.

    I very much doubt there will be frivalous night flights.

    If you do not like it then I suggest YOU move.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by JORDAN KYLE, BS5

    Wednesday, November 05 2008, 8:37PM

    “PETER IS STUPID

    IF ONE OF MY BABIES WAS ILL AND WANTED TO GO TO HOSPITAL THWN I WONT LET HIM STOP THEM BECOS HE WANTS TO SLEEP!!!

    SELFISH MAN”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by ferg, BS1

    Wednesday, November 05 2008, 8:35PM

    “You sound like a right one Peter.

    I can see the BRI from where I live, and any supposed problems with the helicopter would probably affect me more.

    Am I complaining? Have I been consulted? No to both.

    It's as Aristotle would have wanted, we go for the greater good, so if you miss a couple of seconds of Top Gear due to an emergency air lift then so be it.

    No to NIMBYS

    Yes to hospital efficency.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article