Parents' fury as girls left behind

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, July 29, 2010
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

A GROUP of teenagers were left stranded in a seaside resort after a bus driver refused to turn back and pick them up.

The youngsters were among a party of more than 50 who had gone to Newquay in Cornwall for a week's holiday and were due to be brought back to Winterbourne and Patchway.

A number missed the bus hired for the trip because they said they were unaware they were meant to be at a different pick-up point.

By the time they realised, the coach had been on the road for 10 minutes heading back to Bristol. The youngsters contacted some of the party on board by phone but the driver, David Ebbs, refused to go back.

Their furious parents have accused Mr Ebbs of abandoning their children.

But Mr Ebbs said the youngsters knew where they should have caught the bus, he had waited beyond the time he was meant to set off and could not return because of regulations covering driver hours.

Michelle Williams, of Park Avenue, Frampton Cotterell, said her daughter Stacey, 16, was "worried sick" when she realised she had been left behind. She said: "She had no money and the mobile phone reception wasn't very good. I was going to fetch her but in the end the father of one of her friends booked some train tickets for them."

Mrs Williams said her partner, Jason Lewis, met the bus when it returned and spoke with Mr Ebbs. She said: "He just didn't care. How would he have felt if it had been his daughter left behind?"

Stacey said: "I was really upset. I only had about 4p left but we'd already paid for the bus and I didn't need any more money. I didn't know how I was going to get home and I was really scared."

Many of the youngsters went to Newquay to mark the end of their time at Winterbourne International Academy and Patchway Community College and did not all know each other. The bus had been booked through one of the students, whose teacher mum, Judith Barlow, is Mr Ebbs' partner. They each paid £20 for their return ticket.

Stacey said she understood the bus would collect them from the place where they had been dropped off. She said she and Charlotte, also 16, got there in time, only to discover they should have been elsewhere. Charlotte's dad, Craig, of Elming Down Close, Bradley Stoke, said: "The ones who went were all 15 and 16. It's just not acceptable to leave kids like that behind."

Charlotte said about nine were left behind – a figure disputed by Mr Ebbs who understood it was five. She said: "I was angry and worried but we did all get home safely."

Mr Ebbs, who is self-employed, said he agreed to take the teenagers for the cost of hiring the coach and it was "absolutely, totally and emphatically clear to them" where they had to be picked up.

He said: "I arrived early and left 15 minutes late. I didn't go back for them because in a coach, you can't turn around on those narrow Cornish roads until you get to the main road.

"Saturdays are bad for traffic and it would have taken me an hour to do that. I'm constrained by driver hours so was precluded from going back. Also, why should I, or anybody else, inconvenience those who did make the pick-up because of a handful who didn't? They're old enough to have an unsupervised holiday but they were not there when the coach left.

"I gave up two days to take them and bring them back. I did it as a favour but it's just caused me a lot of anxiety."

12
Tweet this article
Report

12 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Bagpuss, At work

    Friday, July 30 2010, 9:35AM

    “I have no sympathy for the teenagers at all - they knew what time they were due to be picked up. As they are permanently texting on their mobiles - why didn't they check with each other why some weren't where they should be.

    I'm glad they came to no harm - but why should the driver risk his livelihood just because they decided to return in their own time expecting everyone to wait for him.

    Having lived in Cornwall for many years I know that the roads are mostly narrow and winding and it is almost impossible to turn eround and re-trace your routes in a car - let alone a coach.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Bagpuss, At work

    Friday, July 30 2010, 9:35AM

    “I have no sympathy for the teenagers at all - they knew what time they were due to be picked up. As they are permanently texting on their mobiles - why didn't they check with each other why some weren't where they should be.

    I'm glad they came to no harm - but why should the driver risk his livelihood just because they decided to return in their own time expecting everyone to wait for him.

    Having lived in Cornwall for many years I know that the roads are mostly narrow and winding and it is almost impossible to turn eround and re-trace your routes in a car - let alone a coach.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by cath, kingswood

    Friday, July 30 2010, 6:19AM

    “I cant believe that a 15 or 16 year old is allowed to spend a week alone in newquay.
    Dont blame the coach driver, if they are considered old enough to be unsupervised by adults for a week then the parents obviously feel they are capable of coping with an emergency,
    parents should have made sure the children had extra money for such events
    I”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Shirley, Bristol

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 4:49PM

    “Broken Bristol, you're spot on!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Laura, Whitchurch

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 3:51PM

    “I feel for the people in cornwall. Unsupervised kids down there = trouble.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Vic, Bristol

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 3:28PM

    “Hey, girls, put it down to a lesson in life. Nobody came to any harm and I am sure you learned more than they could teach you in school.

    The bus driver is not always going to be your dad, so pay attention next time!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by isitoveryet, Bristol

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 12:46PM

    “Sounds like the selfish behaviour of those that have been mollycoddled by their parents and believe the world should revolve around them and then whinge when they discover that it doesn't. If the rest of the group could get to the right place at the right time there's no reason these couldn't either.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Ratsmasher, Bristol

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 11:22AM

    “@Graham
    Got to laugh at you ! Dunno if you have any kids but I'll wager if you do you would have been one of the biggest whingers about the driver on here saying he should be sacked, flogged etc.
    As far as Jon, Outside Bristol is concerned anyone who blogs one here knows he is a miserable so and so anyway- Go and pop some more footballs that come over your garden fence Jon !”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Graham, Bristle City

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 10:59AM

    “What next !!!
    Hold up trains boats and planes because a few people have not listened to boarding instructions. The fact that these days we have the ability to phone people on the vehicle and ask them to get the driver to "turn back and collect us" does not mean this is a god given right.
    Tough luck...as we used to be told !!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by ratsmasher, Bristol

    Thursday, July 29 2010, 10:47AM

    “What a miserable old fart! Getting one of the other kids to call the one left behind so they could be told where the new pick up point was obviously a bit complex for his brain !
    Waiting another ten minutes for them would hardly have killed him would it ?
    With tahat attitude he should work fof First, they are always rude, bully disabled passengers etc. He would fit in perfectly !
    Nice one Blakey !”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters