Nurse won't go back to work if she has to hide her Christianity

Trusted article source icon
Friday, February 06, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

The West nurse suspended for offering to pray for a patient will refuse to return to work if she is forced to hide her Christianity.

Caroline Petrie's comments come as the NHS releases new guidelines for health workers on discussing religion.

Mrs Petrie, from Weston-super-Mare, was suspended without pay on December 17 after an elderly home visit patient complained to the NHS.

North Somerset Primary Care Trust threatened disciplinary action and said she breached a "personal and professional commitment to equality and diversity".

On Thursday the authority backtracked by issuing a statement saying it would welcome her back to work after her case provoked a national outcry.

But the 45-year-old mother-of-two said she would only go back if she was still allowed to offer prayers to her patients – and her lawyers said she may seek compensation for loss of earnings.

Yesterday, Mrs Petrie, a bank nurse, said her employer had still not contacted her directly and she only learned of her fate through media reports.

"At the minute I'm really happy to go back to work but it all depends on what conditions they set," she said.

"If they put conditions on me going back to work and said that I wasn't allowed to offer prayers to patients, well, I just wouldn't accept that. I wouldn't go back. I just can't separate the two things."

Mrs Petrie has been a Christian from the age of ten when her mother died of breast cancer. She switched from Church of England to the Baptist faith nine years ago.

"I simply cannot divorce my faith from my nursing. That's who I am and a part of why I went into it – I wanted to be a nurse from the age of seven," she said.

But the guidelines, set out in a document called Religion or Belief: A Practical Guide for the NHS, state that staff should be wary of expressing their religion in such a way that may be viewed as 'preaching'.

It reads: "Members of some religions ... are expected to preach and to try to convert other people. In a workplace environment this can cause many problems, as non-religious people and those from other religions or beliefs could feel harassed and intimidated by this behaviour.

"To avoid misunderstandings and complaints on this issue, it should be made clear to everyone from the first day of training and/or employment and regularly restated that such behaviour, notwithstanding religious beliefs, could be construed as harassment under the disciplinary and grievance procedures."

The Department of Health said the document was a guide to encourage awareness for staff and patients.

"The guide recognises that for some groups evangelising is part of their religious practice, which for some staff or patients can cause offence or discomfort. The guide suggests, to avoid misunderstanding or complaints, that as part of staff induction staff are made aware that this practice could be construed by some patients or staff as harassment.

"Feedback from trusts that were part of the consultation exercise for the guide indicated that this was a real issue, and something on which they were seeking guidance."

12
Tweet this article
Report

12 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Charles Henry, Somerset

    Tuesday, February 10 2009, 11:05AM

    “You can't even read the story Jerry. . The lady simply asked if she would like her to say a prayer for her after she finished changing her bandages. . She didn't 'force' anything on anyone. . I think a prayer would be wasted on you anyway Jerry. . People would recognise that immediately, so I shouldn't worry about it.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by jerry Jones, Dorset

    Monday, February 09 2009, 9:33AM

    “If i had a nurse come to see me i would expect her to do what she came for and not try and preach to me. I am a christian as much as you Charles but i don't like to force it down people's throarts. Do the job she's trained for and nothing else. Sorry to say if she can't do that then leave.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Justin, Cornwall

    Sunday, February 08 2009, 8:19PM

    “I must partly agree with Charles on this issue. The lady in question should be allowed to give comfort to people who wish it. We are being dictated to by people who want to destroy freedom of choice. If people feel more comforted by Christian thoughts..then so be it.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Charles Henry, Somerset

    Sunday, February 08 2009, 7:51PM

    “Get a life Negative Croydon!! . .
    I think you are a disgrace to mankind.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by negative, croydon

    Sunday, February 08 2009, 6:20PM

    “I am sure too, that if it is a choice of dying or having a religious nurse caring then it is obvious what the choice would be. My GP is an active member of the church, and I have always thought nothing of it. But now, it will always be in the back of my mind will my GP be having my concerns and wishes at heart, or the dictates of the GP's religion when I'm consulting with him/her. All this nurse has done for me is to bring religion into further disrepute, and create for me distrust of medical professionals that are (or may be) religious.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article