Mandelson's missing millions as Airbus loan cut at eleventh hour, say insiders
Business Secretary Lord Mandelson yesterday gave Airbus a £340 million loan to develop its A350 plane – just over half the cash the planemaker expected.
The announcement was made on a visit by Lord Mandelson to the Filton plant of Airbus UK, where work to design the wings, fuel systems and landing gear for the new plane is under way.
Airbus, which has taken orders for 493 of the A350 jets, had originally asked for the money to help pay for development of the plane, which will start rolling off the production line in 2013, and it employs about 500 of the 5,000 workers at the Filton plant.
But the Evening Post understands Airbus chiefs were told they would receive £600 million, which they originally requested from the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS), when a delegation from the company met with civil servants in London recently.
Airbus insiders told the Evening Post that management were angry at an eleventh hour decision to reduce the requested £600m to £340m because of constraints on Government spending.
But the Government has denied it agreed to loan Airbus £600m, saying the amount Airbus received was the result of negotiations.
A BIS spokesman said: "The discussions with Airbus were always going to be negotiations and Airbus is really positive about the outcome."
The money will go towards research and development costs, helping prevent the firm from going into the red as it copes with a reduced order book during the world economic downturn.
Described as repayable launch investment, the Government assistance will also help create and sustain more than 5,000 jobs within the supply chain across the UK.
Lord Mandelson said the money was not a grant. He said: "This is not a subsidy, this is an investment.
"The taxpayer will get a strong commercial return for their investment.
"The UK's aerospace industry is world class and drives our ability to be competitive on the world stage.
"This agreement is further evidence of this Government's long-term commitment to the UK aerospace industry and its future success. Aerospace is one of the UK manufacturing's crown jewels, and manufacturing is one of the UK economy's crown jewels."
Airbus will start repaying the cash when the first aircraft are delivered.
Industry sources believe that had Airbus received £600m it would have made the testing process quicker and further eased the pressure on its research budget caused by cash flow problems from cancelled orders and slowing demand for its aircraft.
Other European governments involved in airbus production have also been asked for money.
The Government assistance will create and sustain more than 1,200 jobs at Filton and at Airbus UK's Broughton plant in north Wales.
The A350 XWB (extra-wide bodied) project consists of three planes capable of carrying 270-350 passengers.
The French and German governments have already announced support for the A350 and Spain, the other Airbus partner country, is still in discussions with Airbus.
Tom Williams, executive vice president for aircraft programs, said Airbus was "happy" with Britain's contribution, given "the very difficult financial environment the Government faces today".
He added the UK would remain the company's centre of excellence for wing manufacturing.
Bernie Hamilton, national officer for aerospace and shipbuilding for the Unite union, said: "This investment is a vote of confidence for UK manufacturing and a ringing endorsement of the Government's aerospace strategy.
"It safeguards thousands of jobs across the UK, but in particular it is good news for jobs in Wales and south west England."
But the Government's loan has prompted protests from Airbus's main rival Boeing, which called it a "market-distorting subsidy".
A spokesman for the US-based planemaker said it was "disappointing" that state financing for its European rival was being announced less than three weeks before the World Trade Organisation is due to rule on whether the practice is consistent with world trade rules.
He said: "Since its inception 40 years ago, the Airbus business model has relied on risk-free Government launch aid to develop each of its commercial aircraft. Launch aid violates the WTO subsidies agreement and is a market-distorting subsidy that is unique to Airbus.
"Today Airbus and its parent EADS are sitting on a cash pile of 8.1 billion euros. Airbus clearly has no need of financial support from the taxpayer. Airbus should finance its aircraft development using its own cash and commercial loans, which it has repeatedly said it is able to do."
Airbus in Filton will design the plane's wings, landing gear and fuel systems.
GKN, its manufacturing partner, will manufacture parts for the lightweight composite wings for each of the A350 planes at its new plant at Easter Compton near Avonmouth.













24 Comments
View all
by lee, bristol
Monday, August 17 2009, 3:01PM
“Jefferson you are such a anus i did my name as lee and also lk which is still part of my name sometimes i use the other anyway whats all this bnp stuff i don't like labour it does not mean i am a bnp voter are you just plain stupid there are 3 main parties plus the green , ukip , loony party etc etc . So if i like football does that mean i get into fights all the time .”
by Alfred, Bristol
Sunday, August 16 2009, 11:54PM
“Chris the system that we live in now is the one to be scared about. As Rich said unless Ireland say NO to this next vote we can all say good bye to Britain as we know it.
Lets look at this government:
1. Gold reserves sold at the lowest point in recorded history to hold up a currency that we aren't even a part of and now Germany and France are climbing out of recession whilst they keep a foot on Britains head.
2. Dictator leadership, two people running the country, one has been sacked twice for sleaze and the other doesn't know how to lead his party.
The list is endless and it's all points as bad as these....
Perhaps if you take an interest in politics you'd understand that the conservatives biggest concern is having to watch this government build up a £Tn of debt. The conservatives will take 10 years to sort out the problems before labour get in again to create another black hole.”
by john, Stoke Gifford
Sunday, August 16 2009, 10:45PM
“Its all a smoke screen. They are not creating jobs. whats happening is there shipping and outsourcing all the work thats there at the minute. Full production going to china, and to romania. The staff that is free from this will then go to other projects. Not a fact of creating more jobs. If everything was kept in house, and not sourced out, then imagine all the jobs then!!but no. So sorry Airbus. I seen your false lies before, being an ex employee. I seen u mismanage projects and at one point creat a job for a job. No need. This is where your money goes!!!
How about making a deal with the government that all future work would be kept in britain. You take the tax payers money, to put in other people pockets, the french and german side of airbus!!!and Then give them the work!!!
British jobs for Biristh people. Not chinese or romanian!!!”
by Chris, Bradley Stoke
Sunday, August 16 2009, 8:57PM
“Sorry, I seemed to have missed the point here.....but Labour have just allocated £340million to help this great business to employ LOCAL people and LOCAL families to continue through this WORLD recession. I see the multi millionaire George Osborne was saying yesterday that he would not allow big bonuses in the city if the tories got in.....how exactly would he do that as they are not government controlled is beyond me....as Mandleson said yesterday they are crowd pleasers....I am afraid to say this is true. .they have no policies, no ideas, no backbone...be afraid if they get in,,,very afraid !!!”
by Tom, Local
Sunday, August 16 2009, 5:53PM
“Ouch! That really hurt!”