Leader of Bristol City Council: 'Let us be clear: We favour new stadium'

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

DEAR Sir,

I am deeply concerned about the level of bullying – intense, sustained, deliberate bullying – to which councillors have been subjected in the aftermath of last Wednesday's decision on Sainsbury's Ashton Gate application.

A witch hunt has been launched in the press and slanderous lies have been published and repeated on the internet. The councillors have also been targeted personally in vicious emails and threatening phone calls.

Members of the development control committee are not mandated by their political groups on the council. Their function is quasi-judicial and planning law dictates that they make their decisions solely on the merits of the case before them and in good faith.

If on this occasion there was an attempt to influence their decision, it was made by the press – no one else!

A wild hysteria has been whipped up against these councillors and it has been done in an attempt to browbeat them into submitting to the will of the football club and its wealthy chairman. This is an extremely disturbing attack on the democratic process.

Let me be clear. The council, the Liberal Democrat administration and individual councillors have been characterised – irresponsibly and without regard to the facts – as the enemies of Bristol City's plans. Nothing could be further from the truth.

● We are in favour of the new stadium. We're backing it financially.

● We are in favour of the World Cup bid. Bristol City Council has led the bid.

● We are in favour of a new music arena. The Lib Dem administration has called – from the start of this project – for an arena to be included.

If we opposed the project in any way, would we have:

● Agreed to hand over more than £4 million of land to the football club in return for community benefits, including access to sporting facilities?

● Made concessions on the normal requirement for section 106 payments?

● Pumped £250,000 of council funds – and hundreds of hours of officer time and effort – into the 2018 World Cup bid?

● Backed this year's World Cup by screening matches in Queen Square at a cost of up to £80,000?

It's not for me to speak for the development control committee. But it should be remembered that they did pass plans for the new stadium at Ashton Vale earlier this year. Is that an indication of prejudiced opposition to City's plans? It's nothing of the kind.

I am grateful to the Evening Post – which has so strongly demonstrated its interest in these matters over the last few days – for allowing me to put the council's position.

Men and women stand for the council because they want a role in public life. They fully expect to be accountable to the electorate, their decisions carefully scrutinised by press and public.

But what has happened over the last few days has not been an exercise in holding councillors to account. It has been a naked attempt to frighten individuals into doing the bidding of certain interests. We see this as a threat to proper and considered decision-making, which is wholly unacceptable.

Barbara Janke, Leader of the Council

63
Tweet this article
Report

63 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Luke, Bristol

    Wednesday, July 28 2010, 4:50PM

    “More smoke-screen nonsense from our inept politicians, akin to the ridiculous comments of Westminster politicians complaining about so-called 'bullying' following the expenses scandal.

    Come back to Earth, Bristol Politicians, we want a word with you. You are an utter embarassment.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Pete, Stockwood

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 11:27PM

    “Greens = no progress?

    Jase, sometimes real progress happens because people can't just keep on doing things the same old way, and they're forced to think of new ones. Maybe BCFC should realise that.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Billy, no mates

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 11:12PM

    “A lot of City fans pretending to care about Bristol. How about the council invest the £4m in our hospitals instead of lining a tax exiles pocket. That WOULD be good for Bristol

    Can someone give me a list of what Mr Landsdown has done for Bristol?

    When I say done, I mean without making a profit himself.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steve, Central Bristol

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 10:29PM

    “Barbara Janke has surprised many, I'm sure, with this very direct statement, and it's good to see. No doubt half the people wanting to "string up" the councillors who voted against the stadium didn't bother to vote themselves in the last election. Either vote them out next time, set up your own Revolutionary Robins private army, or shut up. But don't bully people if you don't like the outcome of democracy.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by jase, Whitchurch

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 10:14PM

    “I think it is you who are deluded. No Sainsburys mean no stadium. Simple as. We all have big supermarkets in our areas now, it is simply a fact of life nowadays. I am sure we would all love to go back to small local stores but those days have gone. It is a very good compromise that benefits the whole area. Let's all get behind this and bring Bristol out of the dark ages. Who knows, we may even get the trams back next!”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article