Jail for woman who cried rape

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

A woman who falsely cried rape has been jailed for eight months.

Mandy Whittle called police to what appeared to be a convincing crime scene, Bristol Crown Court heard on Tuesday.

Her alleged attacker was arrested and detained for some six hours but a police investigation found his alibi authentic and the alleged rape invented.

Whittle, aged 38, of Park Walk, Pill, pleaded guilty to perverting the course of public justice.

Imposing sentence Judge Martin Picton told her: "Two aspects of this case make it serious.

"Firstly, the case from the perspective of the person against whom you made a false allegation, who was in custody for five or six hours, suspected of one of the most awful offences and for a month did not know how it was going to resolve itself.

"Secondly, the damage to the general process of justice that false rape allegations represent."

Jonathan Stanniland, prosecuting, said Whittle called 999 and 45 minutes later police attended at her home and she gave a brief account of what happened.

Mr Stanniland told the court: "She said she heard banging and (the alleged offender) forced his way into her home.

"He tore her clothing and physically overwhelmed her. She passed out and she had been raped."

The court heard police found torn underwear, vomit in a washing up bowl and a fresh cut on Whittle.

Initially, Mr Stanniland said, she appeared to be a genuine complainant.

Later on she told police she wasn't able to pursue the allegation because of the strain it caused, and she never submitted herself for a medical examination.

Mr Stanniland said: "The alleged offender was arrested and interviewed and he was submitted to a medical. He was detained for five or six hours and he provided a full and convincing alibi.

"He said he had been to a pub, a bookshop and then returned to his accommodation. His 'defence' was that it was an utter fabrication from start to finish."

The court was told witnesses confirmed the man had gone where he said he had gone.

In due course his case closed and Whittle's case opened and, on the day of a planned trial, she admitted wrongdoing.

Catherine Spedding, defending, said her client had been a drug user who was "extremely upset" when her children were taken from her.

She said Whittle had a background of depression, for which she was medicated, and at the time of the allegation had taken too much medicine as well as some drink and was in a poor state of health.

Ms Spedding said: "She was not in a very good frame of mind at all and that is why she made the allegations she did. She regrets it. Eventually she accepted it was a false allegation and she avoided a trial."

Ms Spedding told Bristol Crown Court that the hope was for her client to detoxify from alcohol and reduce her methadone prescription.

20
Tweet this article
Report

20 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Aram, Bristol

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 9:54PM

    “Stories like this get a lot of publiciity, but what you won't read are the far more common stories of women who were actually raped, and were intimidated or shamed out of pressing charges.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Bring back the stocks, Bristol

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 9:49PM

    “Colin. The difference being that MOST rape trials don't end in conviction. In fact the majority of rape cases don't even get as far as court. So, using your logic she should've got off”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Bring back the stocks, Bristol

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 9:47PM

    “Colin. The difference being that MOST rape cases don't end in conviction. In fact, most rape cases don't even get as far as court. So using your logic she should've got off”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Mike, Bristol

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 3:10PM

    “Lets say Sarah I've had dealings.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by colin, bristol

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 1:19PM

    “If he had raped her and was found guilty, what would he have got, 5 or 6 years? Thats what she should get with hard labour.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Eli, Bristol

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 12:59PM

    “She should have been made to serve the sentence he would have received if he had been convicted.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Martin, Clifton

    Wednesday, February 25 2009, 12:13PM

    “Joanne, women who falsely cry rape are as bad as rapists. A man falsely accused of rape might have his life torn up as much as a woman who has been raped. It is a vast waste of police resources, which could be spent chasing real crimes.

    Ms Whittles behaviour humiliates the real victims of sexual crimes, who will have a harder time proving their case when people like Whittle falsely cry rape.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by D'oh, Brizzle

    Tuesday, February 24 2009, 10:04PM

    “Sorry Sarah. Thought it was ANOTHER spelling mistake!!!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by anon, BS2 0QX

    Tuesday, February 24 2009, 8:57PM

    “Hi steve thanks for pointing that out, seriously, you have hit the nail on the head, i think slowly but surely i am turning into one lol”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steve, Bristol

    Tuesday, February 24 2009, 8:30PM

    “What this woman has done is terrible.She deserves jail ,
    Re Anons coment,I wonder if it was a man that had made the false allegation would he have got as long in jail??
    I dont understand how you can say such a thing are you a Feminist who dislikes men”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters