Hospital chief hits out at Bristol hospital drama Casualty

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

TV dramas like Casualty, which is filmed in Bristol, and Holby City are filled with staff acting unprofessionally, the head of a scandal-hit hospital said.

Antony Sumara, who has taken over at Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Hospital Trust, said the programmes were entertaining but showed poor conduct and blatant breaches of patient confidentiality.

Earlier this year, a damning report found "appalling" standards of care at Mid Staffs, with patients and relatives describing "Third World" conditions on the wards.

Mr Sumara called on programme makers to reflect what really goes on in hospitals, where staff have a demanding job.

He said NHS staff either "avoid NHS-based soap operas like the plague or watch them as an unofficial sofa critic".

The programmes may also serve to put off young people who may be aspiring to a career in medicine.

He said: "It can be quite therapeutic after a long day at work to wind down by watching the drama unfold on Holby City and Casualty.

"However, the drama isn't limited to medical emergencies.

"There is a very serious side to these programmes and the influence they can have on the viewing public.

"For example, what impression of a career in the NHS is set in the minds of young people aspiring to be the future generation of nurses, doctors or chief executives when they watch programmes filled with unprofessionalism and poor conduct?

"Nurses, doctors and other staff regularly gossip, flirt and argue with each other, usually while treating a patient at the same time."

He said patient confidentiality was "breached constantly" on the programmes, with cases regularly discussed with patients in full earshot.

"Data breaches are common with patient records left in public areas or, worse, downloaded on to portable devices only to be lost later in the programme," he added.

Mr Sumara said the public are not naive "and the majority of people can separate fact from fiction".

But he said "it cannot be denied that some people may think this is a true picture of hospital life".

0
Tweet this article
Report

Your comments awaiting moderation

Be the first to comment

max 4000 characters