Full-time: Bristol 3 Newcastle 35
Bristol’s Guinness Premiership future hangs by a thread following a calamitous home defeat to relegation rivals Newcastle.
On a grim night for Bristol, they shipped four tries and were second best in every department to a side who had previously failed to win on the road for 14 months in the league.
Newcastle’s victory completed a Premiership double over Bristol – and put an incredible 12-point gap between the sides with nine matches to play.
Bristol are now nine points adrift of Worcester, who host a weakened Bath team on Saturday, at the bottom of the table.
Richard Hill’s side have never claimed to be the most talented team in the Premiership, but they were worryingly beaten for fight and passion by a Newcastle side who attacked with purpose and defended with pride.
Bristol’s pre-match hyperbole had insisted losing was not an option, but there was not a single aspect of the contest they could claim to have won.
Newcastle showed superior creativity, a more effective set-piece and greater heart as they sent Bristol hurtling toward National League One rugby with a ruthless performance.
Geoff Parling, Ed Williamson, Brent Wilson and Andy Perry all crossed to give Newcastle a bonus point they surely could not have even dreamed of, while the excellent Tom May weighed in with 15 points with the boot.
The hosts’ only score was a first-half penalty from Ed Barnes as they offered their most appalling performance since returning to the Premiership in 2005.
Bristol trailed 16-3 at half-time after a disastrous opening period, during which Newcastle displayed much more ambition, urgency and composure.
But, incredibly it got even worse after the break.
The home side were given a major scare inside the opening minute when Newcastle carved open their defence with ease.
Adam Balding’s powerful break set the tone, before the ball was worked wide and Newcastle thought they had scored – only for a forward pass to be given after Tane Tu’ipulotu had found Danny Williams.
The visitors, roared on by about 400 travelling supporters, soon had a 3-0 lead when Bristol infringed at a scrum and May nailed the penalty from a difficult angle.
Newcastle then increased their lead when Bristol made a horrible hash of defending a high kick; the ball bouncing in front of Barnes and Tom Arscott and being snared by the visitors.
They worked it wide, kept their composure and lock Parling barged over, with May converting for a 10-point lead after 10 minutes.
The visitors kept up their high tempo and work-rate – and when Bristol strayed offside in midfield, May punished them by making it 13-0.
Barnes soon cut Bristol’s deficit back to 10 points with a 25-metre penalty after Newcastle killed the ball.
With some points on the board, Bristol began to make inroads but ultimately failed to keep hold of the ball for long enough to cause Newcastle any real headaches.
And the Falcons were next to score, May – who is by no means Newcastle’s first-choice goal-kicker or fly-half – landing another penalty following a Bristol offside.
As half-time approached, Barnes missed the opportunity to cut Newcastle’s lead when he failed with a penalty following an offside and Bristol trailed by 13 points at the break.
Barnes wasted another chance to get Bristol back into the game when, in the second minute of the second half, he pushed a 20-metre penalty off-target after Newcastle had been penalised for not rolling away at the tackle.
Newcastle then had a glorious opportunity to increase their advantage after intercepting possession, but Alex Tait’s long pass floated over John Rudd’s head and into touch on the 22.
Having landed his first four efforts from the tee, May missed his fifth, but Newcastle continued to look the slicker, more dangerous side.
And they soon added a second try, taking an 18-point lead in the process. The busy flanker Williamson broke out of a ruck, raced down the blindside and went over to compound Bristol’s problems.
Hill withdrew the faltering Barnes, replacing him with Adrian Jarvis on 55 minutes, but Bristol looked a beaten team.
And Newcastle increased their lead midway through the second half, replacement Wilson scoring with his first touch of the ball.
The impressive May kicked ahead and gathered, before releasing the pacy Williams outside. He passed back to Wilson, who powered in from 20 metres to add a third Newcastle try. May’s conversion made it 28-3.
Bristol’s resistance was half-hearted – and they suffered the embarrassment of conceding a bonus point try in the final six minutes, replacement Perry forcing his way over after the hosts had been opened up far too easily.
When May converted, Newcastle led 35-3 – and many of Bristol’s long-suffering supporters began to head to the exits.
Bristol: T Arscott; L Robinson, Nathan Brew (L Eves 68), Neil Brew, D Lemi; E Barnes (A Jarvis 55), S Perry (G Beveridge 73); M Irish, M Regan (D Blaney 62), D Crompton (W Thompson 68), R Winters (D Attwood 68), N Budgett, M Salter (capt; J El Abd 51), A To’oala, D Ward-Smith.
Scorers: Pen – Barnes.
Newcastle: A Tait; D Williams, J Noon (S Davey 79), T Tu’ipulotu, J Rudd; T May (R Clegg 79), M Young (H Charlton 73); D Wilson (J Golding 66), R Vickers (M Thompson 67), C Hayman, T Swinson, G Parling (A Perry 73), P Dowson (capt), E Williamson, A Balding (B Wilson 58).
Scorers: Tries – Parling, Williamson, B Wilson, Perry. Cons – May (3). Pens – May (3).
Referee: R Debney. Att: 8,808.












3 Comments
by John, Bristol
Sunday, February 15 2009, 6:27AM
“I was one of the nearly 9,000 people who turned up to watch the bottom two fight it out on Friday, which just goes to show you the level of support for rugby in Birstol.
One of the main reasons the team is struggling is to do with the move that Newport that wasn't, which meant that the club only spent 75% of their salary allowance, fearing much reduced crowds in Wales.
There is no question of Bristol avoiding relegationm but nor can I asee them struggling to win promotion next season. The parachute payment, and the amateur status of the majority of clubs in Division One, means the relegated club has a pretty much unassailable advantage from the off.
So when they do bounce back up, the nw ground can be filled, certainly against BAth and Gloucester, and, should they make the Heineken Cup again, as they did season before last, then for those games too. If the club can get 9,000 whilst rock bottom, then the potential is clearly there for near-full houses when they eventually start to perform again.”
by Valentine Rose, Bristol
Saturday, February 14 2009, 10:45AM
“Really sorry, as an armchair supporter of Bristol Rugby, to see them probably relegated, but it just goes to show what an impossible pipe dream the 18,500 stadium was...neither Rovers nor Rugby are up to it.”
by MendipMan, Wurzel Country
Friday, February 13 2009, 9:52PM
“Been following game on an Internet site and Bristol were hammered 35-3. Very disappointing for all Bristol sports people, not only for the current situation in which the club finds itself but also for the demise of a once great rugby club. I'm afraid Bris will likely join the ranks of past giants now reduced to minnow status - the likes of Coventry and London Welsh.
It is very strange that smaller clubs with no history of success at the top have managed to make a go of it in the Premiership whereas Bristol from a large and prosperous city with a top rugby pedigree has failed so miserably since the dawn of professionalism.
In football this would be the signal for the manager to leave. I suspect Richard Hill, who did extremely well for several years on a shoestring budget, must now be seriously considering his position.
I have a horrible feeling that Bristol will break the recent trend of relegated Premiership clubs bouncing straight back to the top league.
Oh for the days of John Blake whose Bristol team pioneered the concept of 15-man rugby and was by common consent the best club side in the UK at that time.”