George Ferguson: Rail travel is the way to go

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, August 08, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

In an attempt to escape from this summer's unpredictable English weather, I am off on my travels round Europe.

My feet will not leave the ground, apart from taking the occasional ferry.

One of my best investments has been a rail map of Europe – it connects some 6,000 European destinations between the Atlantic and Moscow, more than enough for a lifetime of learning from other places. I think of it as my mobile university.

I start my journey from Temple Meads via the Eurostar to Paris, where I treat myself to a day of wonderful architecture, good food and one of the great travelling treats in the world, the buffet at Gare de Lyon, designed in the flamboyant style of the "Belle Epoque".

The station was built as part of the programme for the great Paris Exhibition of 1900. Its highly gilded and decorated buffet is covered with paintings of the sights and events along the rail network of the time. It cannot fail to lift the spirit while waiting for the train to the South.

I write this week's column sitting in the extremely comfortable second class upper tier on the electrified TGV train, hurtling past changing scenery, towards the Mediterranean.

It is excellent news that we are to emulate the French with electrification of the line between London and Swansea, but I wonder if the UK is to be thwarted from having these sensible two-tier carriages because of the tunnels?

Anyway, let's contrast all this travelling pleasure with the nightmare of airports and flying – the hassle, the restrictions and the sameness of it all wherever one goes – and, of course, the undeniable effect on climate change.

However, we are now told by the Minister for Energy and Climate Change that he wants to protect air travel from restrictions and taxes. Has he been taken in by the relentless campaign by Ryanair's punchy chief executive?

In what otherwise seems a good energy review he foresees continued growth in air travel – a policy of despair. This is softened by talk of the use of bio-fuel for air travel, which would put unsustainable pressure on our precious agricultural land.

This feeble-minded attitude to air travel will unfortunately act as an encouragement to those planning the frightening expansion of the use of Bristol Airport.

The plan is to increase by 60 per cent to 10 million passengers a year by 2016 (the year by when all new houses are to be built to be carbon zero!). This will mean nearly doubling the number of flights, including night flights, and causing two million extra car journeys.

All this has the potential effect of having a climate change impact as great as that caused by the whole of Bristol in 2008, and is at a time when we are marketing the region on its green credentials.

How on earth do millions of holidaymaker passengers driving out of, or past, Bristol bring anything but economic disadvantage to the region? It is no coincidence that as tourist traffic has recently reduced, visits to local attractions have increased.

Great claims are made about the economic advantage but business use of the airport is only projected to be about 10 per cent of total traffic – and most of it is domestic which can better use the trains.

All of us now have just one week to take action. Check www.stopbia.com for information and check out North Somerset's website www.n-somerset.gov.uk referring to application number 09/P/1020/OT2.

Decide for yourself while I go and have a reasonably conscience-free dip in the Med!

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Bill, Bristol

    Monday, August 10 2009, 6:43PM

    “If global warming means we can have more days like yesterday, (09/08/09), you'll forgive me if I don't sell my old V8 Range Rover.

    "I'm convinced that future generations will look back at this era and conclude that we were all barking."

    They'd only have to look at this column.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Mark, Bristol

    Monday, August 10 2009, 9:09AM

    “Rail is a great way to get around Europe, that is if you forget the cost and the unrealiability of the trains in our part of Europe.

    I've lived very near to Gatwick and Heathrow (was in the flight path a couple of miles out of Heathrow) and have to say i don't see the issue.
    Bristol will not be as busy as Gatwick and that was more than fine.

    James - we are the British, that means we have the power to stop global warming just by our country becoming a little better at things like travel. Forget that other countries pump out more than we do by a crazy amount, they are insignificant in comparison to us. We are the cause of global warming, we have to pay green taxes (ha!) to get out of it and save the world...
    Oh wait.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by James, South West

    Saturday, August 08 2009, 8:59PM

    “So if Bristol Airport doesn't expand and people are forced to go to Heathrow and other airports how many more million car journeys will that entail?

    What a load of inaccurate claptrap he is spouting. There will not be a near doubling of flights, neither will night flights be doubled.

    Larger aircraft have shown over recent years that more passengers can fly from Bristol using fewer aircraft. This trend will continue.

    How will four million more passengers equate to two million extra car journeys?

    This assumes that everyone will travel two to a car and will not use any other form of transport to reach the airport.

    Perhaps George would like to go to China and tell them to stop building scores of new airports currently either under construction or in planning, each one far larger than Bristol Airport.

    But like most Green campaigners in this country he likes to play at Green and attack soft option, low risk targets.

    I wonder if he really believes what he writes or is merely filling up some column inches and trying to be a bit controversial to justify what is undoubtedly a pleasant little earner from the newspaper.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steve, Bristol

    Saturday, August 08 2009, 2:31PM

    “Air travel looks so much more attractive because of the ludicrous cost of rail travel in this country.

    Until this is addressed rail can never be seen as viable.

    While European fares are very reasonable the cost of getting to the Channel Tunnel negates any savings making air fares look very cheap in comparison
    and all the hanging around airports in cattle-class seem worthwhile.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Mark, Stoke Bishop

    Saturday, August 08 2009, 10:53AM

    “Enjoy your holiday, George. Rail is definitely the way to get around Europe and it is good to see you leading by example.

    Flying seems to be the true environmental elephant in the room at present. No politician wants to be the one to break the news to Joe and Jane Sixpack that they cannot have their holiday in Spain, but increasing global demand for oil coupled with falling production is likely to spell the end for cheap air travel sooner or later. Currently, though, when one can fly to Barcelona for less then the cost of a day-return rail ticket from Parkway to Paddington, the business case for expanding the airport seems to hold water.

    I'm convinced that future generations will look back at this era and conclude that we were all barking.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters