Parents refuse to send children back to school after gas leak scare
SOME parents are refusing to send their children back to a primary school at the centre of a carbon monoxide scare.
The Manor School in Coalpit Heath was evacuated yesterday after a total of 34 pupils were taken ill, including feeling faint, nauseous or having headaches.
-

Emergency services attend The Manor School in Coalpit Heath to investigate the possibility of a chemical spill or a carbon monoxide leak
-

Catherine Fennell leaves school with her daughter Hannah, 5, in her arms
-

-

-

Catherine Fennell leaves with her daughter Hannah (5) in her arms. 1
-

Catherine Fennell leaves with her daughter Hannah (5) in her arms. 2
-

Catherine Fennell leaves with her daughter Hannah (5) in her arms. 3
-

Catherine Fennell leaves with her daughter Hannah (5) in her arms. 4
-

Headteacher Hilary Eade speaks to the media outside the school 1
-

Headteacher Hilary Eade speaks to the media outside the school 2
-

Headteacher Hilary Eade speaks to the media outside the school 3
-

Pupils Cameron Begbie-Bilkes and Owen Cleaver (both 7).
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 1
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 2
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 3
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 4
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 5
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 6
-

The scene at Manor School yesterday 7
One child was sent home after fainting and when a second fainted an ambulance was called.
Eight pupils were sent home and a further 26 were looked over by paramedics at the school.
Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk
View detailsOur heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.
Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk
Contact: 01858 468192
Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013
As the numbers taken ill rose, emergency services started to investigate the possibility of a chemical spill or carbon monoxide leak.
Police cordoned off the school in Roundways Road and children were taken out to a field nearby.
Last night head teacher Hilary Eade said rigorous checks had confirmed there were no problems with the school's boiler or gas supply and said the school would open as usual today.
A doctor called in to assess the situation said the sudden outbreak of illness was most likely to have been caused by a virus.
But some parents said they were not satisfied that the school was safe for their children to return and told the Post they would not be sending them in today.
As the youngsters were assessed yesterday afternoon, worried parents were directed to the nearby Miner's Social Club on Badminton Road.
By 5pm all pupils, including those taken ill, had been checked over by medics and allowed home.
Emergency medicine consultant Dr Phil Cowburn from the Bristol Royal Infirmary said he was satisfied after all investigations that no children were seriously ill or that any serious incident had occurred.
Dr Cowburn said he believed it was likely the sickness was as a result of a viral bug easily spread in schools.
"The children affected have been checked over and we are entirely happy that nothing serious is going on," he said.
Dr Cowburn said children had been tested for carbon monoxide levels and found they were "not significantly elevated". But he said he was unable to completely rule out the presence of carbon monoxide at the school because he was not an expert.
One parent asked him if he would send his child back to the school given the circumstances and he answered that he would.
But Amy Bennett, 27, and Shane Danter, 42, of Coalpit Heath, did not want their five-year-old daughter Shaya to go to school today.
Ms Bennett said: "She's not going to school, not without enough information. Who's to say she won't be ill when she's there? What if another 30-odd children are ill?
"It's not like they could be sure it was a stomach bug. It's not like they know what caused it.
"I won't be sending her to school until they are 100 per cent sure."
Mr Danter said: "I don't think it's right for the kids to go to school. That many kids don't just get sick for no reason and it hasn't been limited to one class."
Parent Catherine Fennell, who has two children at the school, said: "I am not terribly keen on sending my children back because we don't know for sure what happened. When so many children fall ill, and are not from one class, it makes you very nervous."
Another mum, who asked not to be named said: "I don't know what to think. We are all discussing whether our children should go back. I don't think we will be sending ours back because we have not been told categorically what happened."
Mrs Eade, above, said: "I know some parents were concerned about communication but we communicated with them the best we could given the circumstances.
"The fire officer has assured me there is no evidence of carbon monoxide in the building. We know parents were naturally concerned but the children and staff were amazing."
A spokesman for Avon Fire and Rescue Service, who deployed four fire engines and two chemical response unit vehicles, said they were contacted at 1.30pm and worked alongside police, ambulance, and South Gloucester- shire Council.
"The school was evacuated as a precaution while a multi- agency response was quickly put into operation," the spokesman said.
"A total of 34 children appeared to be displaying some minor symptoms. Eight were sent home, the remainder assessed by ambulance staff, and nobody was taken to hospital.
"Firefighters have conducted a search of the premises and found nothing to cause undue concern."
The school's website said it would be open as usual today.




Comments
by Samantha1883
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 6:48PM
“Whatever it was that caused this a lot of children were ill yesterday and people on here saying that some kids only felt ill because other children were is pure speculation. Whether it was chemicals, virus or "mass hysteria "either way they should just shut the school until at least next week to make a full investigation. I also wouldn't want my child breathing in the chemicals of "12 months worth of disinfectant" being chucked down in 3 hours such as was reported on the other article.”
by Morrissey9
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 4:55PM
“It sounds like mass hysteria, a couple of kids feel faint or ill, then you ask some of the others how they feel and suddenly they think they feel ill also. Add some theories about carbon monoxide and it seals the whole thing off. I can see why the parents don't want to send their kids in, as soon as a single parent keeps their child home you'll just look bad for sending yours on their own to face up to the (non-existent) chemical leak!”
by katachua
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 4:13PM
“@A_Mushroom
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 2:06PM
"This apparent hysteria is being perpetuated by the likes of this article that has a headline that suggests a gas leak, and a first line that mentions carbon monoxide, yet buried within the story is the assurance from the fire brigade that there is no evidence of carbon monoxide in the building."
Indeed. It's a good few years since the gas supply contained carbon monoxide, anyway.
As you say:
"Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story and scare the wits out of parents."”
by Jonnyfandango
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 3:37PM
“I bet i know the sort of parents that kept their children home today.”
by michaelacrump
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 2:47PM
“the Mass hysteria was made worse by silly reporting, if the facts are reported and not all the "it may be's" then parents would not be so worried . the emergency services did a great job keeping all of us informed and instructing us in what to do. the teaching staff and headmistress need a big pat on the back for keeping the children calm and remaining so themselves. we can be greatful it was nothing too serious and put our faith in the school and the emergency service's who did their best not to make a bad situation worse. massive thanks go to the school cleaning staff and caretaker who were in a 5am this morning to satisfy us all that the school would be fit for the shildren and staff to return .”
by A_Mushroom
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 2:06PM
“This apparent hysteria is being perpetuated by the likes of this article that has a headline that suggests a gas leak, and a first line that mentions carbon monoxide, yet buried within the story is the assurance from the fire brigade that there is no evidence of carbon monoxide in the building.
Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story and scare the wits out of parents.”
by katachua
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 1:39PM
“@Pogo_T_Clown
"A virus? That's saying "We don't know what caused it". In that case, I'd keep my kids at home for a couple of days as well.
It probably -is- nothing but my kids' safety comes first. 34 kids going down sick is too much of a symptom for me to write it off as mass hysteria."
On the contrary, it's the best indication that it IS mass hysteria.”
by BCFCfinker
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 11:48AM
“Your not going to convince these parents, so let them wrap their kids in cotton wool and keep them home. Once the rest of the school has been back for a couple of days, they'll then scuttle back to school safe in the knowledge that they 'did the right thing' protecting little Cuthbert and Jemima from the unknown.
After all, these parents know more than the experts... Google is their friend (along with mumsnet.com, parentsareus.com and frightenedofeverything.com).”
by Pogo_T_Clown
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 11:18AM
“A virus? That's saying "We don't know what caused it". In that case, I'd keep my kids at home for a couple of days as well.
It probably -is- nothing but my kids' safety comes first. 34 kids going down sick is too much of a symptom for me to write it off as mass hysteria.”
by GrumbleDuke
Tuesday, July 10 2012, 10:54AM
“What a load - no one has been hurt, get the kids back to school and stop whining. It is doubtful there will ever be 100% proof of the cause so what is the course of action then?”