Funding and issues of race
On Saturday, the Post reported that black Liberal Democrat councillor Shirley Brown used the term "coconut" to describe Asian Tory councillor Jay Jethwa.
"Coconut" is a term used by black or Asian people to describe someone who is seen to have "sold out" his or her own people to the "system", hence "brown on the outside, white on the inside". It is very offensive.
-

I know Cllr Brown, she is not racist, but on that occasion her words clearly were. No doubt there will be long, hard soul-searching for all concerned.
But what led up to this unforgivable outburst? As reported in the Post, Cllr Jethwa was supporting a Tory proposal for funding cuts. In an interview with the Post, she said: "This authority is spending many millions of pounds specifically on Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) projects and groups. This expenditure covers a huge array of spending areas ranging from adult community care, youth provision, housing, racial social awareness and improving educational attainment. One has to ask how effective many of the measures we have adopted are in the long term."
There is a certain truth to these concerns; there is also a certain naivety. For a long time now, I too have been arguing that a lot of money is being pumped into community groups that have little or no output. But the answer is not to cut funding from all of them; it is to have more effective evaluation and accountability processes.
To question the supposed millions of pounds being spent on BME communities is also misleading. BME communities also pay taxes. They also have a right to expect services and facilities that cater for their specific needs, as we all do. I would understand the mindset behind the Tory proposal if it also wanted, for example, to cut the funding of the Bristol Domestic Abuse Forum (BDAF) because, despite its existence, we still have rampant domestic abuse in our city.
What the Tory proposal seems to forget are the many individuals who have had their lives transformed for the better and even saved by the existence of the BDAF. The same applies to the many BME groups that deliver equally vital services. Without many of them, Bristol would be a far more divided city.
The fact that some of our communities are still facing major problems in Bristol indicates the scale of the situation we are facing. It shows what community groups are up against and shows we need more funding, not less.
Cllr Jethwa also spoke of her own experiences as an immigrant from Uganda, working hard to succeed and not having to rely on such community groups. She should count herself lucky; immigrant communities always work hard but not all succeed.
In a recession, it is tempting for politicians to target the more vulnerable in our communities for whatever reason, whether to save money or for political expediency. It is for that very reason that in times like these, we should remind them of their responsibilities to all the people of our city.











18 Comments
View all
by Anon, Bristol
Saturday, March 07 2009, 10:56PM
“Typical. Again some people trying to victimize themselves belw...”
by Shelly, bristol
Thursday, March 05 2009, 6:25PM
“Oh Adam come on now that idea is both sensible and fair which is why our local councils/national govt would never even entertain the idea...!”
by Adam, Bristol
Thursday, March 05 2009, 10:23AM
“It seems obvious to me - democracy should be implemented. Calculate the percentage of people in the city are of ethnic persuasion, and spend the same percentage of the city's money that has been set aside for community projects. Spend the rest of the money on majority, non-ethnic community groups. Seems fair.”
by Shelly, Bristol
Wednesday, March 04 2009, 6:19PM
“George. I don't know anyone who judges another on Race and it's appalling that the society we live in is putting pressure on ordinary people like yourself to have to prefix comments with a race. This shouldn't be happening. It makes ordinary people sound racist - even if they are not.
The other point is that an insult is an insult no matter what. It shouldn't be worse just because someone's race is involved. I have been called an ugly fat 'C' before now and I felt humiliated and frightened . adding the word 'white' wouldn't have made me feel worse.
No one should be allowed to insult or belittle another. All insults should be treated equally with the seriousness it deserves. depending on the context not necessarily by the words that are said.”
by george, Briz
Wednesday, March 04 2009, 6:02PM
“Good comment Shelly, in the point i was making it is the first time in my life i've used the description 'white communities' Reading such rubbish in the evening post is affecting my thoughts and i must say, not in a positive way.”