Fortune favours Bristol City in win over Crystal Palace

Trusted article source icon
Monday, August 17, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

Bristol City 1 Crystal Palace 0

Events at Ashton Gate merely served to confirm the old adage that what goes around comes around.

A week earlier, it had been the turn of Bristol City players and supporters to feel hard done by when a controversial refereeing decision cost them victory over Preston North End at Deepdale.

If Callum Davidson's injury-time penalty on the opening day of the Coca-Cola Championship campaign gave rise to righteous indignation within City ranks, Bristolians could hardly have expected things to even themselves out quite so quickly.

But that is exactly what happened when Crystal Palace were denied a perfectly good goal, scored by Freddie Sears after 33 minutes.

The teenage loan signing from West Ham United skipped through City's defence and clearly beat Robins keeper Dean Gerken with a shot which crossed the line before hitting the net framing and bouncing back out.

Somehow, referee Rob Shoebridge convinced himself that Sears had shot wide and, following lengthy consultation with his linesman, awarded a goal-kick, much to the relief of the home side.

Palace manager Neil Warnock and his players were understandably incensed. They knew it was a goal, City's players knew it was a goal and so did those supporters sat close at hand in the Atyeo Stand.

Appreciating a lucky break when they see one, those same fans gave the referee and his assistants an ironic standing ovation as they left the field at half time.

Imagine Palace's sense of injustice when Nicky Maynard popped up two minutes from time to score a dramatic winning goal his side scarcely deserved. But such is football.

Recalling the slings and arrows of outrageous misfortune which befell himself and his team-mates seven days earlier, match-winner Maynard afterwards suggested that these things "even themselves out" over the course of a season.

Warnock was, understandably, not so phlegmatic, feeling a draw was the very least his young team deserved from an afternoon of frustration and toil.

Even Bristol City boss Gary Johnson was inclined to agree. Although delighted with Maynard's last-gasp winner, he admitted his team had been fortunate to win.

He said: "To get a goal at that time was fantastic for us and demoralising for them. I was just pleased we got the points.

"If we couldn't have a good team display on the day, then it was important we had a lucky one. I'll accept the three points, but on another day we could quite easily have lost this game 1-0."

It would have been easy for City's players to have become embroiled in the controversy that followed the disallowed goal. But Johnson had more important matters to attend to after seeing his side fall short of expectations in the first half.

Fearing a tunnel bust-up at half-time, Johnson sent his players back out onto the pitch ahead of schedule to prepare for the second 45 minutes.

He explained: "I thought it was going to be a little bit heated in the tunnel, so I took my players back out. Neil was obviously disappointed with the disallowed goal. We didn't know why it had been disallowed ourselves, but we decided to let Neil have his say with the referee and to not get involved.

"We had a bit of work to do ourselves. We had not been doing well up to that point and we certainly didn't got our football going. We needed to make one or two changes in personnel and shape and we needed to be calm to do that.

"We competed well throughout the game and they stood up to be counted. But we gave the ball away too many times and that's why I changed things."

Johnson's decision to withdraw David Clarkson, introduce the bustling John Akinde, switch to a 4-3-3 formation and go man for man all over the park certainly made a difference and City were at least able to put their opponents under pressure after the break.

But it seemed the afternoon would end in frustration for both sides as chance after chance went begging in a scrappy game littered with fouls.

Akinde twice had shots saved by Julian Speroni, Ivan Sproule blasted over when well-placed and Paul Hartley had a goal ruled out for offside, while Darren Ambrose was denied by Dean Gerken on two occasions and Paddy McCarthy headed wide from a corner when hitting the target was a minimum requirement.

Television replays showed Hartley was on-side and his goal should have stood, a fact which put Warnock's post-match complaints into perspective.

No matter. Just when it seemed the contest was going to end goalless, up popped Maynard to do what he does best and complete a bad day at the office for the visitors.

Speroni's attempted clearance struck Jose Fonte and the ball fell invitingly at the feet of Bristol City's record signing, 20 yards from goal.

Controlling the ball in an instant, he returned it with interest, curling his shot beyond the helpless keeper and into the bottom right-hand corner of the net to register his second goal in three games and claim the spoils for his side.

"That was my one clear-cut chance of the game and, thankfully, I took it," reflected Maynard.

"Their keeper kicked the ball to me and, once I'd got it out from under my feet, my first thought was to whip it round him. Fortunately, I've managed to do that."

He added: "I thought the gap between our centre-halves and the forwards was too big in the first half and we kept lumping the ball long. That was not going to help me against two big centre-backs, so we changed formation to 4-3-3.

"John Akinde was a real handful when he came on and I felt we looked more like scoring after the break.

"In the end, we've been a bit lucky. But some weeks you're lucky and some you aren't, and we'll take this."

1
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by ian hall, London

    Monday, August 17 2009, 2:38PM

    “Jumping to conclusions

    I was at the Bristol City .v. Crystal Palace game on Saturday and can not believe the ignorance people are showing regarding the disallowed Crystal Palace goal. It is no more correct to say a good goal was scored by Freddie Sears of Crystal Palace than Paul Hartley of Bristol City.

    Neil Warnock and Simon Jordon immediately, without having the decency to first consult the referee, jumped to the conclusion that the goal was disallowed because the officials missed the fact that the ball had crossed the line.

    Just suppose you were the honest linesman and had spotted an infringement, possibly the fact that a Bristol defender, Cole Skuse, was pushed off balance when Freddie Sears ran through to the scoring position. (There were many harsh decisions during the game, many of which could be argued were too harsh and perhaps the officials got wrong. Most notably a Bristol City goal was wrongly adjudged to have been offside).
    As an honest linesman you raise your flag to signal an infringement. It is a fact that the linesman signalled for the referee to go to him rather than the referee initiating the communication.

    What then followed was utterly disgraceful behaviour by Neil Warnock and Simon Jordon. Without hearing the officials story they jump to the conclusion that the reason for disallowing the goal was that they missed seeing the ball going over the line. Without hearing any of the evidence they make the following accusations
    1) The Officials failed to see that ball went over the line. Did Warnock have the courtesy to ask the referee if this was the case?
    2) The Officials were about to lie by saying that there was an infringement. I find this utterly deplorable. Only a true yob could make such a comment.
    3) Without knowing the full evidence, like a loose cannon they turn on their opponents and call them cheats. Gary Johnson is one of the most honest managers in football and once, when manager at Yeovil ordered to gift a goal to Plymouth Argyle when it was certain that an injustice had occurred.

    The referee¿s report has now indicated that the goal was disallowed for an infringement. (This would explain why the linesman called for the referee rather than Visa Versa). I hope in the light of this evidence Neil Warnock and Simon Jordon have dignity to apologise for jumping to such a wrong conclusion.

    Some members of the press can also be accused of jumping to the same conclusion rather than having the courtesy to first listen to the officials. I hope they too have the decency to make an apology.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters