Farooq Siddique: A sign of 'Islamic power' or just a place of worship?
A couple of weeks ago, the Swiss voted to ban the building of any more minarets – there are only four in all of Switzerland.
The right-wing Swiss People's Party's (SVP) advertising campaign, which proposed the ban, included a poster featuring a menacing black burkha-clad figure standing in front of an arsenal of black minarets that looked like missiles rising up from a Swiss flag.
Prior to the campaign, no mosque had ever been attacked in Switzerland – now, many have.
The SVP says minarets are a sign of "Islamic power". It's part of a growing campaign across Europe and here in the UK, spreading fear that Muslims are "taking over".
Mosques are simple places of prayer that are paid for entirely by the communities they serve – many are poorly resourced. Most here in the UK are small converted terraced homes, shops, halls, pubs and the like. All of them are filled beyond capacity, every week, for Friday afternoon prayer. They are not symbols of anything, except practical places of worship.
The minaret is not a crucial element of the design of the mosque; neither is the dome. Both, traditionally, serve a practical purpose; one for the Muezzin to climb to the top to make a call to prayer, and the other for better acoustics inside the hall. A mosque is still a mosque without either. In principle, banning minarets is no big deal for Muslims. But there is still concern.
Would we equally restrict the design of, say, synagogues, temples or churches? Some see Muslims here being given special favours: "Why are there no churches in Saudi Arabia?" they ask.
It's true, there aren't any; but it's for the same reason there are no mosques in Vatican City. Both are holy sites for their respective faiths. A Hindu wouldn't ask to build a temple at Lourdes, for example.
Churches exist in every other Muslim nation on Earth; Pakistan alone has hundreds of churches and cathedrals. In Qatar, the Emir donated the land on which a $7 million church was built. Egypt is home to some of the oldest Christian communities on Earth – and so on and so forth.
For some though, even my column is a sign of "Muslims taking over". I assure you, there's no such agenda. True Islam conquers hearts, not walls. God asks in the Quran: "If it had been the Will of your Lord that all the people of the earth should believe; all the people of the earth would have believed! Would you then compel humankind against their will to believe?"
I ask for nothing more than to worship freely. I would support the same right for anyone, anywhere.











17 Comments
View all
by Mary, Redfield
Tuesday, December 15 2009, 10:50PM
“Well done to the Swiss. Let's hope the rest of Europe follows suit.”
by The Hedgehog, Horfield
Tuesday, December 15 2009, 9:20PM
“Can we PLEASE have a decent-sized box to type into AND a review facility. The current system makes everybody look like morons because we can't see what we've typed or correct it.
Grr!”
by The Hedgehog, Horfield
Tuesday, December 15 2009, 9:17PM
“"annoying palindrome" - now, that's what I call abuse ;)
One the communication problems here is that, as Ms Palindrome correctly points out, many people tick the C of E box without any commitment to Christianity.
Muslims who, by and large, take Islam seriously, do not understand that a majority of the "Christian" community have no religious faith at all. Their ethics may be Christian, but that's about as far as it goes.
I've met many Muslims who've showed great respect for the Christian faith that I do not, in fact, have. I suspect that they find it much more difficult to get their heads around a secular society than a Christian one.”
by hannah, bristol
Tuesday, December 15 2009, 7:20PM
“thanks for response jim,you know people keep going on about the koran and all the bad parts in it, im willing to bet that most muslims do not live by some of it in the Quran,its the same with christians, how many people confess to being christians and state that when filling out forms?its suprising how many people tick the C of E box, but how many of them have actually read the bible properly? its not even close to 10% yet they think they know so much about other religions.”
by hannah, bristol
Tuesday, December 15 2009, 7:13PM
“john? i did not report you, as i copied your name it copied the report abuse on the bottom right, i can honestly say i am not into reporting anyones comments, i never have been.”