Empathy can never be biased

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

LAST week, in a live television interview, Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd could barely contain his emotion as he talked about the loss of life caused by the bushfires that ravaged parts of his country. He described the ferocity of the flames as "hell on earth".

The imagery conjured up by that phrase is frightening. We all understand exactly the gravity of what he is describing. Hundreds died. They were people like us; living in a First World country, watching the same TV shows that we do, watching the same movies, speaking the same language, and wearing the same types of clothes that we do.

Their sons and daughters could be our sons and daughters. Their parents are like our parents. So, when they hurt, we share that pain, immensely, deeply. We want to hear their stories; of their survival, of their loss, of their pain, as though somehow, by knowing it, we could help them ease it.

But we don't feel like that about all people. What of those who live in the Third World countries? They have their own TV shows. They have their own movies. They speak a different language. They wear different clothes from us.

It's true for all people, all over the world. Jews naturally empathise with other Jews. Christians naturally empathise with other Christians. Muslims naturally empathise with other Muslims. Children naturally empathise with other children, whites with other whites, blacks with other blacks, Republicans with Conservatives, Democrats with Liberals – like with like; a Noah's Ark of empathy.

In recent weeks, I've been criticised by some because I have empathised with the people of Palestine. I've been accused of being anti-Semitic, an Islamist and much more. I understand now, though, that those accusations are not because I am any of those, but it is because those who have accused me have not felt empathy with the suffering of the Palestinians, because they do not have anything in common with them.

Perhaps I, too, have fallen victim to that same empathy bias. Perhaps I, too, have been blinded to the suffering of the people of Israel.

Perhaps I, too, have not felt sympathy for the deaths of three Israeli civilians as compared to the deaths of 412 Palestinian children.

The Lord of all the Worlds has no such bias. In the Koran, the words of God are simple; taking the life of one innocent soul is equal to taking the life of every innocent soul on Earth.

And for falling into the trap of comparing numbers, I ask forgiveness.

How we empathise with others is how, I believe, we can gauge our own tolerance of others. Do we truly consider others equal to us? Is all life truly sacred? Do we truly understand the plight of others?

Our biggest fear here is getting a speeding ticket as we cruise in our cars to and from work. Their biggest fear is that the tank that has just left will turn around and come back.

The extremists, the fanatics, the dictators and the terrorists, all those who advocate violence to achieve their own aims – are they not just far further down the road of intolerance that we, by our lack of empathy, have only just begun to travel?

7
Tweet this article
Report

7 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Anon, Bristol

    Saturday, February 21 2009, 9:46AM

    “Why this columnist is allowed to preach this diatribe week after week is astounding.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by daisymeadow, Bristol

    Friday, February 20 2009, 5:11PM

    “Good on you Sarah,

    Its heartwarming to hear of your actions and goodwill. Take no notice of the put downs, there are always bitter people around, frustrated by their own impotence.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Englishman, Bristol

    Friday, February 20 2009, 3:57PM

    “The lengths to which this columnist will go every week to regurgitate his incitement for anti-Israelii sentiments amazes me. Linking fires in Australia to Palestine is tenuous in the extreme.

    How about writing something useful and pertinent? Let's hear his views on Abu Qatada and what the Muslim community is doing to get rid of the other preachers of hate who infest this country.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steven, North Bristol

    Friday, February 20 2009, 2:19PM

    “Well Sarah, some students have passed a motion and are occupiying some space. The Isreali government must be quaking in their boots.

    You're at school to learn, so why not do so and leave politics to the grown ups?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Sarah, St George

    Thursday, February 19 2009, 5:07PM

    “In a gesture of solidarity with the people of Gaza, Students of the University of the West of England, Bristol, have passed a motion of support for the people of Gaza and are currently engaging in a peaceful occupation of a space within the University.
    This is following the recent atrocities that have and continue to take place in the Gaza Strip & occupation of the West Bank. We as students ourselves wish to offer our unity and support to our fellow students in the region during these hard times. We have proposed a set of demands of the University including scholarships for Palestinian students, a boycotting of Israeli goods, support for fundraising for DEC, and a condemnation of Israeli Actions in the region.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters