Call for diabetic drivers' tests after Bristol woman's death
The family of a Bristol woman who was killed by a driver suffering a low sugar attack has called for the introduction of compulsory blood tests for diabetics before they get behind the wheel.
Relatives of "bubbly and happy-go-lucky" Pamela Beckett spoke out after an inquest heard she was hit on the pavement by a car being driven at up to 60mph by a man who had suffered a hypoglycaemic episode.
The 37-year-old had been walking with her boyfriend from Temple Meads station to her home in Totterdown when she was thrown 15ft into the air after she was struck by a Vauxhall Astra being driven by diabetic James Higgs.
Mr Higgs, 33, who lives in Barrs Court, Longwell Green, told yesterday's inquest at Flax Bourton he was not aware of the onset of his "hypo" because he had not pre-tested his blood sugar level before driving and had no warning symptoms.
He said he had no memory of the crash and had not been advised to always test his blood before getting behind the wheel.
Miss Beckett's sister Carol Brown said the accident highlighted shortcomings in the "management" of diabetic
drivers and believes people with Type 1 diabetes should be legally bound to test their blood sugar levels before driving.
She said: "We don't want another family to go through the same thing we went through.
"What's happened shows that diabetic drivers should be made aware that they need to test before they drive and regularly while driving."
In a statement read out at the hearing, Miss Brown said there were five fatal crashes every year and 45 serious accidents in the UK every month involving drivers suffering hypoglycaemic attacks.
Avon deputy coroner Terry Moore echoed Miss Brown's calls for action when he recorded a narrative verdict into the death, which he described as accidental and a "tragic incident".
Before he concluded the case, he heard that diabetics only received guidelines on driving if they requested them from the DVLA.
Mr Moore said: "At the very minimum, this information needs to be sent to every Type 1 diabetes sufferer and needs the recommendation that sufferers self test before taking the wheel of a vehicle."
Mr Higgs had been travelling from the city centre to see a friend at a pub near Temple Meads station when the accident happened at 4.45pm on January 21, 2007.
Mr Higgs said he had suffered less severe hypoglycaemic attacks before but said he was not aware of the effect an episode would have on his driving.
He told the inquest he received his driving licence back from the DVLA in March and now tested his blood sugar level before driving using a blood glucose monitor.
In January, Mr Higgs was told he would not face a charge of causing death by dangerous driving when he appeared before Bristol Crown Court. Judge Jamie Tabor QC asked for a not guilty verdict to be recorded.
A DVLA spokeswoman said: "DVLA works with health professionals, Diabetes UK and other organisations to ensure newly-diagnosed diabetics receive information about the implications for driving and their obligation to notify the DVLA."
Director of care at Diabetes UK Simon O'Neill said: "Diabetes UK recommends that people with diabetes check their blood glucose levels before they get behind the wheel and regularly during the journey."













33 Comments
View all
by Jennifer Warren, London
Thursday, September 03 2009, 1:04AM
“Firstly, my sincere sympathies to Pamela's family. Last month, my husband and I were waiting at traffic lights, quite stationary when we were hit from behind at 60mph by a diabetic driver in a hypo. This was the most terrifying experience of my life. My husband, who was driving, saw the car coming in his rear view mirror. Our car was written off and we both suffered spinal injuries and are still in a lot of pain - to say nothing of the psychological effects we have suffered. The other driver's insurance company are doing all they can to delay a pay out for our car. The main purpose of our car was to transport our son, who is a double amputee. He was not in the car at the time of the accident. If he had been, he could not have survived, the damage was so horrific. So he's now stuck inside unless his friends visit to take him out. We just cannot afford a replacement vehicle until the insurance pays out. I have had insulin dependent diabetes for 40 years myself and I (and every other diabetic I know) has warning signs if they are going into a 'hypo'. The driver that hit us had only travelled 5 miles before the accident so he must certainly have known he was not fit to drive before getting behind the wheel. He obviously neglected to perform a blood test. This irresponsible person has caused a great deal of loss and suffering to my family. It is about time the DVLA tightened up on regulations for diabetic drivers. Compared to poor Pamela and her family, we have got off lightly. How much more heartbreak are those who fail to manage their condition going to inflict on others?”
by Hayley, Bristol
Thursday, June 11 2009, 5:58PM
“As far as i am concerned, no one should be punished for having a condition such a diabetes, or any other. We have to live with this condition every day through no fault of our own, but it is completely tragic someone has died as a result of a 'hypo'.
This could have happened to someone with an unknown case of diabetes, or another condition which resulted in them having an 'attack' at the wheel, what would be said then 'its their fault, they should have known better, they should have been tested before they got in the car?'
I dont think so, sometimes we just have to accept that tragic accidents happen.
Condolences to the family.”
by Dave, Bristol
Thursday, June 11 2009, 2:35PM
“I'm amazed that most of these comments are concerned with protecting the rights of diabetics (who I do have every sympathy with), rather than looking at how tragedies like this can be avoided in the future. How sad.”
by Sandra, Bristol
Thursday, June 11 2009, 1:57PM
“Matt, I don't think Sharon was putting words in your mouth, the heading of this story states it wants ALL diabetics to have blood tests before driving, which probably wouldn't have made any difference to the outcome. Try looking at this from the other side of the fence, if it were you with diabetes!”
by Dee, Bristol
Thursday, June 11 2009, 12:55PM
“Matt: I don't see how really any party can get on with their lives but they have to try.
Its was not like he went out to do this was it.
I know how the driver is coping which is not good and how he DOESN'T live his life like he used too and some of the information that has been written is not fully correct as i know what happended and the information from this case.”