Cross party? They all make us cross!
Cabinet member Peter Hammond has made two concessions this week to opponents of aspects of Bristol City Council's Primary Review strategy.
He has offered to meet representatives of the group fighting proposals to expand Sefton Park Infant and Junior Schools and has also agreed to participate in a cross party working group looking at the proposed closures of three primaries.
Mr Hammond says he wants to find a way forward on both issues.
But he insists that the working group will focus only on the plans to shut St George's Church of England Primary School in the city centre, St Pius X Catholic Primary in Withywood and Stockwood Green Primary and not on the wider issues of the review's strategy.
He also points out that the Sefton Park expansion is not part of the review, but was agreed by the council last January.
Liberal Democrat leader Barbara Janke and Tory leader Richard Eddy both say there should be more cross party working with regard to children and young people's services.
The Lib Dems feel they should be consulted over big issues because they are the largest party on the council and the Conservatives hark back to the time of the shared administration when their party had the education brief in the cabinet.
But Labour, albeit in the minority, is running the council – at least until the elections – and is taking the tough decisions so it has up to now seen no need for compromise.
Scores of teachers, governors and parents have attended council, cabinet and scrutiny commission meetings over the last few months to state their case against the Primary Review proposals.
For many, it has been their first view of how local government works – and they have been shocked at what they have seen.
They cannot believe that knockabout politics, electoral concerns and short term fixes are involved in decisions that can have such a profound effect on children's futures.
They, and many others who have never been near the council chamber, would surely agree with Mr Eddy when he says: "We need a primary strategy that will survive over many decades irrespective of which political party is in power."
But how will this be achieved when attitudes are so entrenched?
All parties would do well to remember the events of the past decade, which saw the council come within a whisker of having its control of education taken away by the Government after two damning Ofsted judgments.
There has been relative stability over the past four years, but while there was consensus in 2005 when results were at rock bottom, it has dissipated considerably.
The new chief executive Jan Ormondroyd has agreed to set up the cross party working group on the closures. Many observers hope she will tell them all how cross they are making many teachers and parents.







3 Comments
by JohnPaul, Ashley Down
Tuesday, December 02 2008, 10:20PM
“Some examples of that knockabout politics that we have seen.
Councillors delaying the start of Public Business in Council Meetings in the hope that parents with restless children will have to leave and so be unable to read out their statements
Councillors dismissing protesters as a vociferous minority and claiming public support for their plans, then unable to produce evidence of that support when pressed
And the latest shocker
Council Leader Helen Holland allowing her photograph to be used on promotional material for the PR company assisting the Cricket Club in their opposition to building a new school at Brunel Fields, while claiming the Cricket Club have had no influence behind the scenes, something we have suspected all along.
Some might call this corruption. This administration will pay the price at the ballot box next year.”
by Valerie, St Andrews
Tuesday, December 02 2008, 2:21PM
“It will be good to get some straight answers to some vital and as-yet unanswered questions we in the community have about the proposed expansion which is a bad idea all around. Why not build a two-form entry school on the Brunel site? or take a fresh look at the old Fairfield School building on Ashley Down?”
by Joel, Ashley Down
Tuesday, December 02 2008, 10:35AM
“The people of Sefton Park also want to find a way forward on the problem of a lack of primary school places in the area. We hope that Peter Hammond's offer to meet is not just a delaying tactic to take the issuse out of thepublic eye whilst plans are implemented behind the scenes. Expansion of Sefton Park is NOT the answer though. This would be a very short term fix at an unacceptably huge cost to the whole community. A new school should be built on the Brunel site and Gloucestershire Cricket Club should accept that they are operating in a congested city environment. They cannot assume that their car parking problems take precedence over Bristol's children and their education.”