Chaos? What traffic chaos

Trusted article source icon
Friday, September 26, 2008
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

It was hard to know whether to laugh or cry as I sat in the city council’s traffic management control room on Thursday morning.

In all the build-up to the opening of Cabot Circus, much of the talk in our office here was of the impending traffic chaos which would doubtlessly follow.

So, while most of my Evening Post colleagues were dispatched to the new cathedral of consumerism in the city centre, I had the more prosaic task of heading to St Paul’s to visit the control room in Wilder Street.

I was greeted by a bank of monitors surveying CCTV footage from around the city, with a side-room containing a master computer which finely tweaked all the traffic lights in the centre to optimise traffic flow.

Part of me - my news hack side, I suppose - was keen to see some congestion, traffic jams stretching up the M32, overcrowded car parks or even city centre gridlock (the jackpot for all the doom-mongers).

It would have made great writing, watching the traffic boffins desperately coming to terms with an unstoppable river of fashion-crazed shoppers, as smoke crept under the door of the overloaded computer room.

So as I sat there eating biscuits, drinking coffee and chatting to those in charge... was I the only one there who felt a sense of anti-climax when nothing much happened?

There I was, with my fellow reporters sharing the excitement with the rest of Bristol, while I sat in an office in St Paul’s with nothing to do.

But there was also a sense of relief that Bristol, with its much-maligned history for organising major transport initiatives - supertram, anyone? - had for once pulled something off without a glitch.

Excuse any unfounded optimism here but perhaps Cabot Circus’ opening heralds an era where Bristol actually gets things done.

When I started working as a journalist in Bristol five years ago, the city’s roads were the number one issue which bugged many of our readers here.

I was amazed at the vitriol reserved for our bus operator and the contempt with which the local transport authority was regarded.

And for the last three years - almost two of which I have spent specifically writing about transport - the redevelopment of Broadmead has loomed large on the horizon as a massive challenge facing those in charge.

How on earth could thousands of shoppers be absorbed into a city centre which already creaks under the pressure of commuter traffic?

But looking at the roads around Newfoundland Circus on Thursday morning, I was impressed at how they had suddenly be transformed.

Perhaps the fire and brimstone of the developers, along with their multi-million pound pockets, held some sway over the speed and quality of the outcome.

And while no one could ever accuse Bristol of being especially spacious, once the new bus lanes were uncovered the wide, multi-laned area looked impressively modern.

Don’t get me wrong, there is still lots to do and Saturday morning may well prove to be the time when the lack of a park and ride site at the top of the M32 is first truly bemoaned.

But what we at the Evening Post must do here is hold those taking the decisions to account, criticise when necessary but also give credit where it is due.

So I couldn’t help feeling pleased for the people involved, that their plans had worked out and, as hoped, traffic was flowing fluently around the city.

There is still lots of work to do further afield, of course, with the public transport network needing particular attention.

But Cabot Circus’ opening was always going to be a landmark day in the city’s history and the same can be said from a transport point of view.

Little by little, the city is becoming the serious city it has always had the potential to be.

Some might argue that it is losing a vital part of its character in the process but, from a transport point of view, drastic measures need to be taken.

Now is when we see the transport masterplan for the area coming into fruition and those in charge have passed their first test.

Time will tell if they can put the rest of it in place equally as smoothly and Saturday will be a further acid test.

1
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Peter Brown, Barton Hill, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 28 2008, 10:41AM

    “Don't make me laugh.

    As being a past professional who spent a considerable part of my working life on the roads, Bristol is second only to London for artificially induced congestion.

    When I first came to Bristol, there was a perfectly good fly-over to take local city traffic away from the Temple Meads area. You could also take the slightly longer route around the old Grosvenor hotel to take the same route past St Mary Redcliffe. Since then a bunch of idiot traffic engineers who wanted to maintain their inflated highways budgets took away the fly-over (citing maintenance costs) then proceeded at far greater cost to close the route around the hotel and force all the local traffic through together with the through traffic along a much longer route past the station (which was already heavily congested), across the feeder and back again to where they would have originally exited the fly-over. In peak times, this can add around a quarter of a mile and up to 15 minutes to negotiate. Further, on the opposite side of the road, they reduced the two traffic lanes to one with a bus lane. A good idea to have a bus lane you might think but the idiots forgot that the bus lane had to rejoin the congestion on the single lane waiting to join the roundabout at the Grosvenor. Even the later introduction of Bus Driver controlled traffic lights did very little to improve things as due to the traffic light control (sic) sequence on the roundabout did not allow the segment to clear to allow new traffic from Redcliffe to join. Because of the single lane, the waiting traffic allowed only 2 or 3 extra cars to join the segment before everything came to a standstill again leaving other drivers fuming at a green light whilst often leaving the two furthest lanes of the roundabout almost free of traffic.

    East Bristol drivers attempting to by-pass the city traffic to travel on the through routes to Bath and the South West use Cattle Market Road. There is interminable delay here because there is just a 15 second sequence on the traffic lights at the Temple Meads system and because it is essentially a single lane, allows just a very small number of cars through. Drivers on Cattle Market Road then have to wait around 3 minutes before the lights change in their favour again. What is even worse, the traffic approaching parallel to the feeder is forced by the roundabout layout to turn right up the congested Bath Road and drive a further two miles or so to return to the feeder route.

    Cabot Circus is just more of the same. Through traffic used to be able to drive straight on towards Temple Meads through a working light controlled junction. It now has to travel a considerable distance up towards the M32 only to do a ¿U¿ turn through a different traffic light sequence into the heavily congested traffic from the M32 to arrive back at precisely the same point as the original junction.

    I dread the inevitable roadworks in the early months of each year as the City Traffic Engineers scramble to squander the remains of their over-inflated budgets on further hare-brained schemes which naturally slow the traffic even further and cause massive pollution as the vehicles sit there with the engines idling in the traffic jams.

    Forget congestion charges. If the City was serious about reducing congestion, they should sack the Engineers and let the traffic control itself. Deregulation of traffic is a proven method of maintaining traffic flow.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article