Bristol worker claims boss 'forced her from job she loved'

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

by Julie Harding

A Bristol recruitment consultant is taking her former boss to a tribunal, after claiming she was forced out of the job she loved because she wanted to work part-time after taking maternity leave.

Emma Archer, who has had two babies, gave evidence yesterday at the industrial tribunal where she said her former employers Cavendish Maine, had discriminated against her because she is a woman.

She said the final straw came when she overheard her boss running her down and describing her as "a pain in the neck".

Mrs Archer, who is married to ex-Bristol Rovers player Lee Archer, is claiming sex discrimination, unfair dismissal and discrimination for asserting maternity rights.

If the Bristol tribunal panel rules that she was discriminated against on the grounds of gender there is no limit on the amount of compensation that can be awarded.

Mrs Archer, of Blackcurrant Drive, Long Ashton, also claims that she was not given a contract and that Clifton-based Cavendish Maine was in breach of contract.

She told the industrial tribunal that she was one of the firm's top sales people and loved her job, which she had held since 2002.

She went on maternity leave in January 2005 and, after having her daughter Ava, returned to work three days a week in January 2006.

In September that year she took a second period of maternity leave, returning in October 2007.

Mrs Archer recruited people for the food service industry but in her absence no one covered for her.

She said this contrasted with other women who took shorter periods of maternity leave whose jobs were covered in their absence.

Six weeks after she returned to work she was called in for a chat with boss Nick Hester about how she was getting on and in December, at another meeting, was told she was being considered for redundancy. Mrs Archer told the tribunal: "I was singled out for redundancy because I work part-time. There was no other reason.

"I knew I was one of the best sales people there. I had a lot more experience than staff who had just joined."

Mrs Archer challenged the redundancy and she claimed she was told her job was safe.

But she said she was excluded from meetings and generally made to feel unwelcome.

The final straw came on December 21 last year when the firm's AGM was held at Hunstrete House hotel near Bristol.

In the coach on the return journey Mrs Archer sat in a seat in front of Mr Hester who, she claimed, was drunk and unaware that she was nearby.

She said he was talking about her on his mobile phone in a "horrible way". She said: "He was talking about getting rid of me. He said 'I was watching her, I saw her give Howard filthy looks.. it's disgusting. She's a pain in the neck.

"Let's hope she goes. The sooner the better."

Mrs Archer quit her job saying she had been treated in a "subversive, unreasonable and discriminatory" way.

Cavendish Maine denies that it discriminated against Mrs Maine in any way.

Nick Hester and other staff were due to give evidence at the Bristol tribunal on Thursday.

30
Tweet this article
Report

30 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Bert, Bristol

    Friday, November 28 2008, 2:17PM

    “Let's hope none of the anti workers rights people on here don't have cause to regret their words by being crapped on from on high by their employers during these difficult economic times.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Gary, Cornwall

    Friday, November 28 2008, 12:46PM

    “Grahame thats a very good point. This person is allowed to damage her former employers without redress, what a confused world we live in.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Anon, Bristol

    Thursday, November 27 2008, 10:00PM

    “Oh and I have not replied sooner, because I have just sat down for my evening meal at approx 10pm at night. I was up at 6am, prepared my children, prepared myself, made lunches, tidied, started my day job, worked solidly through lunch, got home past 6pm and again made sure the kids were settled, fed, watered, had some cuddles and kisses. Then began the housework, spent some time studying for my college courses and finally have sat down.

    I have a secret to tell you, I am actually not superwoman........................ I am a part time worker!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Anon, Bristol

    Thursday, November 27 2008, 9:50PM

    “Dear Lord Clifton, it is because I am aghast at the sheer narrow mindedness of some of the opinions expressed on here. Everyone has their own opinion on these matters, but most of the negative ones are severely misguided judgements. Based on no facts and inaccurate information.

    There is the insinuation that we should all remain childless in order to be equal members of society. Or if not, then to stay at home and look after our children. If I did that, I would need benefits.

    Which beggars belief considering so many of you complain about others scrounging off the state, I for one work my hardest to be a great mother and role model for my children, provide them with decent food, a decent roof over their head and work my absolute face off every day and night to do this. Parenting is a full time job regardless. Working part time is not actually working part time at all! There are jobs suited for part time working and many employers find that part time workers are actually an asset to their businesses. Let it be known that many 'part-time' workers end up working full time work loads during a shorter period of hours and therefore should be deemed not as 'incapable' as has been implied' but actually far more efficient than any full time working employee. Depends on the type of business and service being provided of course. But I for one guarantee that when I work my part-time job I work extremely hard to juggle both my personal and professional life and give my best to both. I think we part-timers deserve a little more respect than the degrading, spirit crushing comments that have been made.

    Is this a fair enough point for you oh Lord Clifton...??????”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Lord Clifton, Clifton

    Thursday, November 27 2008, 9:12PM

    “Mandy and Anon, I dare say you have some valid points to make. It's a shame you drastically reduce the likelihood of anybody taking you seriously when you have to resort to sexist language like "MCP" and "little boy" in order to make them. Kind of ironic too seeing as you frown upon the supposed sexist treatment of others when it suits you.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article