Bristol's naked statue could return

Trusted article source icon
Sunday, January 11, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

The naked statue of a man which stood for months on a green in Bristol until planners ordered him taken down is making another bid for stardom.

Sculptor Rebecca Johnson-Marshall, of Marlborough Hill, Kingsdown, has put in a planning application for the "fully endowed" concrete statue on Montague Green, at the bottom of Kingsdown Parade and Montague Place.

She was forced to remove the original "pirouetting jester" figure, made with cement and papier mache, by city councillors on Bristol's development control committee last April.

But the artist vowed to fight on, claiming it would have been different if the sculpture had been of a woman.

She said the real reason for rejecting her application was distaste for a piece of public art that showed a man's genitals.

"If it had been a woman's breasts, that would have been different," said Ms Johnson-Marshall. "I thought the world had moved on, but obviously not."

The committee almost unanimously rejected their own officers' recommendation to approve the sculpture.

When many of Ms Johnson-Marshall's neighbours told her they liked the sculpture, she decided to make it a permanent feature.

But the committee decided it was not designed as a long-term installation.

"There were concerns about what it would look like in a couple of years' time," said a city council spokesman.

The council had received 45 letters – 33 in favour, 12 against.

Neighbours have been consulted about Ms Johnson-Marshall's plans to install a new almost entirely sand-and-cement statue on the same site - for three years only.

After that the hope is that the site can be used for other public art chosen through competition.

Comments in the consultation say that this a great idea. Several say how much people have missed the Jester since he was last on Montague Green.

Objectors last time said the jester's nudity was offensive and agreed with the council's public art officer's verdict that the sculpture was not good enough to be considered a permanent work of art.

But supporters said the sculpture "makes a positive contribution" and provided "an entrance feature" to Kingsdown.

Ms Johnson-Marshall said: "There's nothing offensive about the sculpture. It has genitals, but then every man has. I can't see what's wrong."

The new statue will be stronger and "slightly less sexually explicit", says its creator.

14
Tweet this article
Report

14 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Derek Crane, Shirehampton (but moving soon)

    Monday, January 12 2009, 5:33PM

    “The statue was fully clothed when first erected. The trousers fitted me perfectly but the shirt was too tight, I have muscles on my arms. I left it with undergarments, where are they now?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steve, Isle of Detection

    Monday, January 12 2009, 5:13PM

    “Correct me if I am wrong ~ didn't an earlier photograph show the statue wearing a Gucci watch?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steven, North Bristol

    Monday, January 12 2009, 12:07PM

    “The sole reason this "work of art" should not be permitted is that it's damned ugly.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Prof. P S Sawhney "PAUL", Chandigarh [India]

    Monday, January 12 2009, 11:54AM

    “I congratulate the Sculptor Rebecca Johnson-Marshall for such a bold initiative.She is perfectly right when she says:"There's nothing offensive about the sculpture. It has genitals, but then every man has. I can't see what's wrong." Fortunately she has been supported by a majority of critics 33 as against 12. Freedom of expression is a fundamental right and the artist has not exceeded her limits of decency in installing the sculpture. God bless you.Bravo! Keep it up.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by GingerRog, Bristol

    Monday, January 12 2009, 9:27AM

    “I don't think I would like to meet this statue on a dark evening sat on the grass somewhere ~ with or without his great big potato, Space Monster!

    I think he could do with a facelift too!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Space Monster, Bristol

    Monday, January 12 2009, 9:15AM

    “"Fully endowed" ? Yeah, right ! Looks like a potato to me.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by GingerRog, Bristol

    Monday, January 12 2009, 3:53AM

    “But what more could we ask for Steve, all skin and bones and "fully endowed" too!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Derek Crane, Shirehampton (House for sale)

    Sunday, January 11 2009, 8:37PM

    “Thanks for pointing it out, Steve, I wouldn't fancy that "entrance feature to Kingsdown"”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steve, Isle of Boggling Minds

    Sunday, January 11 2009, 8:24PM

    “Half a dozen lines from the end:
    "the sculpture (of a naked man)....provided an entrance feature".”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Alex, Bristol

    Sunday, January 11 2009, 8:17PM

    “Couldn't have been me ginge, I was too busy riding my bike on the pavement to model for it and talking to my mate George...”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters