Bristol's councillor in 'coconut' row in bid to battle suspension

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

The Bristol city councillor at the heart of the "coconut" race row has applied for leave to appeal against her month-long suspension.

Liberal Democrat Shirley Brown was suspended by the authority's standards committee at the end of last month, preventing her from attending meetings or dealing with official council business.

The suspension has meant she is also unable to claim her monthly councillor's allowance.

Mrs Brown has applied to the Adjudication Panel for England Tribunal Service for leave to appeal.

The service president will decide later this week whether to grant an appeal hearing or dismiss the application, based on the likelihood of success.

If the appeal is allowed, Mrs Brown's punishment will be stayed pending a further decision from the adjudication panel.

This would allow her to resume her council duties.

The panel would then have three options; to dismiss the standards committee finding, to uphold it or to impose a different, potentially more severe sanction.

An appeal could take up to 12 weeks and could be dealt with by either written submissions from all parties or a tribunal hearing that would be held in Bristol.

In addition to her suspension, Mrs Brown was censured and rebuked for comments made to Conservative colleague Jay Jethwa at a full council budget debate in February.

Mrs Brown, who is black, called Mrs Jethwa, who is Asian, a "coconut" – a term used to describe someone who is seen to have "sold out their culture", being dark skinned on the outside but white in the middle.

The comment came after Mrs Jethwa supported a failed Tory proposal to cut funding for the Legacy Commission, an organisation that supports black people and ethnic minorities in Bristol.

The standards committee found Mrs Brown's behaviour had brought the council into disrepute, and she had not apologised soon enough.

But the committee did not believe the equalities aspect of the council's code of conducted had been breached.

The committee – made up of two independent members and a Labour councillor – had been given a report by council official Shahzia Daya that had recommended no further action be taken against Mrs Brown.

Ms Daya concluded that although the comment had a racial element to it, it was not racially abusive, and Mrs Brown's apology via the press was sufficient.

The committee disagreed, a decision which shocked Mrs Brown.

Further questions are due to be raised about the ongoing row at tonight's full council meeting.

Councillor John Goulandris, the Conservative who sat in with Mrs Jethwa at the standards committee meeting, has posed a number of questions for Liberal Democrat and council leader Barbara Janke.

He asked what assurances could be made the incident would not be repeated; whether Mrs Brown would be undergoing further equalities training and what internal disciplinary procedures the party has carried out.

Speaking ahead of tonight's meeting, Mrs Janke said: "Councillor Brown has unreservedly apologised for causing offence. Councillor Brown has applied for leave to appeal."

Mrs Janke said any subsequent requirements on Mrs Brown would depend on the outcome of any appeal.

She said she would remind the council the report of the investigation into the February incident found that there had been no breach of equality laws, this was an isolated incident and there was no intent to bully Mrs Jethwa.

The Post tried to contact Mrs Brown yesterday but she was unavailable for comment.

Spokeswoman for the adjudication panel Sharon Penn said: "We have received an application for appeal from Councillor Brown.

"If the appeal is refused we write to all parties and that is where it ends.

"It has not been decided yet, the president will decide sometime this week."

23
Tweet this article
Report

23 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Drownyerpuppy, St pauls

    Wednesday, July 22 2009, 9:31PM

    “She a bumbaclot.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Archie, Ashley Down

    Wednesday, July 22 2009, 3:07PM

    “Why are Paul Stephenson and Robert Mugabe never seen in the same room at the one time .”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by soarer, Bristol

    Wednesday, July 22 2009, 7:52AM

    “Is Alan J Maggs an anagram of stupid idiot? No it isnt is it. Should be. She isnt saying white is bad at all. The comment is made towards a non-white. Plenty of names for people who are white but pretend to be black. Small towns are full of em. But when it is said it isnt being derogatory towards black people, saying black people are bad. Numpty.
    I think you will find Paul Stephenson is rather too an important figure to speak out about rather a pathetic little spat you foolish individuals. The battles he fought were more important. Is he supposed to be pulled out, at his age, to comment on every single accusation of racism!!!??? Get a grip.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Alex, Mangotsfield

    Wednesday, July 22 2009, 6:41AM

    “Well spotted Archie, you are right. Where is Paul Stephenson in this racism row ? it would appear that the only racism Paul is interested in is slavery ,& that is way back in the past where it should stay ,but to quote Archie why is he now conspicuous by his absence?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by NoWhereMan, NoWhereLand

    Tuesday, July 21 2009, 6:24PM

    “AmorinBristol,

    'I'm all for free speech, unless it's from the BNP.'

    It's not free speech then is it?”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters