Bristol residents fear hospital will block light

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, July 23, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

People living behind South- mead Hospital believe their homes will be overshadowed by new buildings that have been planned close to their homes.

The proposed main building will back onto Dorian Way, which is just a few metres away from the gardens of five houses in Dorian Close.

Residents believe the three- to five- storey buildings will block sunlight from their gardens and be intrusive.

They have been shown light plans by the developers and are angry they were not consulted about the design sooner. The worst affected houses are likely to be in Dorian Close, although there is likely to be some impact on homes in the Dorian Road end of Tilling Road.

Fiona Deas, 54, said the light at her home was one of the reasons why she and her husband Alistair chose to move there two years ago.

But plans for the new hospital will leave her garden in almost total shadow. A tall chimney can already be seen from her garden, but the new building is likely to block all of her view.

Mrs Deas said: "We actually bought the house for the light and it was not until we saw the plans that we realised it would be gone.

"When we first heard the new hospital was going to be here we thought it would be great; we don't have a complaint about the hospital.

"No one saw anything in the original plans that alerted us to this, it all started further down the road. We are really quite amenable to lots of things with the hospital.

"It says in the planning statement that we are already living by a hospital, but it's a car park now, not an A&E department open 24/7.

"I know people say about not in my back yard – but this really is going to be in our back gardens."

A couple who have lived on the row of houses that back onto the proposed site of the main building for 18 years, but asked not to be named, can already see single- storey hospital buildings from their garden and want the new building to be moved further back from the edge of the hospital site.

One said: "We were quite excited by the whole idea of the new hospital and thought it would be nice for Bristol, but about a month or so ago we saw the plans and realised it was right by our back garden.

"My wife came back from the meeting in tears. She suffers from SAD (seasonal affective disorder, which is brought on by lack of natural light in winter) and could not bear the thought of the loss of light.

"I went along to the next meeting and asked them about moving the building back, but they were not going to.

"We have seen diagrams of how the buildings will affect the light and in the summer we will have nothing but a small triangle of light by 6pm, whereas at the moment we get the sun until 9pm at night in the summer. Even by 3pm it will have most of the garden in shadow.

"It seems to be that because they are only affecting a handful of people in a street, they don't seem to care."

Planning documents for the redevelopment have acknowledged the close proximity of the proposed buildings to their back gardens.

Suzanne Osborne, 60, has lived in Dorian Close with her husband Peter for 30 years and has seen the mental health high dependency unit built close to her own back garden.

She said: "It's the sheer size of it really. The people suffering more are those living at the bottom of the close, it is going to overshadow the gardens.

"I am also concerned about the traffic. It is a nightmare now trying to pull out onto the main road so I can't imagine what it will be like with a bigger hospital. I think it is just too much in one area, especially with the 300 homes they are building where the prefabs were.

"They should have built the hospital at Frenchay."

Josie Jackson has lived in the close for seven years.

She said: "We are concerned that in the plans the hospital looks quite close to the houses. It does not affect us as much as the neighbours across the road.

"In our old age being close to a hospital it will be nice and I don't disagree that the hospital should be built there and that there should be a new hospital, but I am slightly concerned that the plans will bring all the ambulances down Dorian Road.

"There is also the building work going on behind us where 100 prefabs are being turned into 300 dwellings and to have the road as the main entrance to A&E is a concern, especially as it is a bit of a blind corner."

In the supporting statement which has been submitted with the planning application there is a section referring to the different impacts the building will have on neighbours.

It states that trees will be planted to screen the views as much as possible.

NBT deputy director of projects Tricia Down said: "We fully recognise that there are going to be a small number of neighbours who will find it difficult to have a hospital of this size close to their homes. It is a pity that we have not been able to come up with a solution that does work 100 per cent for every person but this will be a good thing for the local community. It is a fantastic resource, a state-of-the-art hospital for them, their loved ones and children... One of the problems is that the existing hospital needs to keep running throughout the building so the available land is a little closer to some of the houses."

Ms Down said Carillion and the trust would be meeting with residents living near the hospital regularly to keep them informed.

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Martin, Not near a hospital

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 5:33PM

    “Wait until hospital visitors start parking in their garden and body parts start getting put through their letter box for disposal.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by SAD Sufferer, Bristol

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 1:19PM

    “To most of those who have commented below: On reading the article it seems that the residents don't have a problem with having a new hospital, and think it is a good idea just not literally the other side of their garden fence.

    As a sufferer of SAD I can understand their concerns about lack of natural light so to call them selfish is a bit harsh, especially if they are being overlooked - how would you like to lose your privacy?

    Adrian - if you think the 'simple' answer is to move, then perhaps you would to buy one of their houses so you can admire the hospital close up and very personally! They have no doubt looked into moving but have found that the value of their property has dropped signficantly due to the hospital!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Ian, Bristol

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 12:54PM

    “Mrs Deas; who has ever bought a house because of the light? That's a new one on me. Tough! And to the unnamed resident whose wife suffers from SAD, dont you ever go further than your garden in winter?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Chris, Bristle

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 11:38AM

    “Relatively simple maths could tell them for certain whether they will be in shadow. So no need for doubt.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by derek, Nuremburg

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 11:02AM

    “Nothing from the residents about the sick & injured.Surely theSun still goes from East to West still so where is all the light you will be losing?I have to say,Frenchay seems a better site but now the decision has been made,live with it.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by michelle, Bristol

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 10:19AM

    “I'd be more worried about the ambulence sirens! Well at least they can get some descent shut eye with all that darkness ;)”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by NOT A NIMBY, Somewhere

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 9:02AM

    “So the rest of Bristol should suffer just so you can have some light? Very selfish, don't you think?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Sam, Bristol

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 6:47AM

    “This is why the 'super' hospital should be built at Frenchay! I've just had a quick look at the plans on their website and it is pretty scary how big and close the building is to people's houses - I wouldn't want it that close. Ok, they are going to plant trees - how big are these trees going to have to be and what happens when the leaves fall off!!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Adrian, Bristol

    Thursday, July 23 2009, 6:41AM

    “Bunch of NIMBY's, If you don't like it, move, its quite simple.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters