Bristol residents' £1.5 million fight over "collapsing flats"
Residents living in luxury flats overlooking Bristol's Floating Harbour have launched a £1.5 million legal action after they were forced to prop up their collapsing balconies.
They are taking developer Crosby Homes to court next month after balcony ceilings at the award-winning £14 million The Point development caved in.
The 115 people living in the apartments, built near the ss Great Britain in Wapping Wharf in 2001, have been forced to shell out thousands of pounds on repair work and wooden struts to prop their balcony roofs up.
They have also complained of rainwater leaking through their balconies and problems with electrical fittings inside their flats.
Don Joyce, 57, a semi-retired management consultant who owns two apartments at The Point, criticised the standard of workmanship on the development.
He has lived there for five years and paid £260,000 for his two-bedroom apartment and £350,000 for his three-bedroom property.
Mr Joyce said: "The workmanship could have been a lot better. I've had interior work done and tradesmen who've been here have said 'who the hell put this up?'
"It appears the work was rushed, not properly planned and not properly supervised. All of my light units have had to be replaced because the transformers have been badly wired.
"We all want this sorted because it's a wonderful place to live and the management company do a wonderful job."
Problems with the balconies began on New Year's Day in 2007, when a soffit fell on one of the balconies on the Westgate building, one of the five buildings in the development.
Wooden props were put up on the balconies of 16 flats to stop the cement boards falling and they remained in place for 10 months because Crosby and subcontractor Skanska failed to repair them, say residents.
Residents eventually raised £50,000 for repairs to 50 apartments but in summer 2008 a soffit on a flat in the showpiece Pennon Rise building also gave way.
Surveyors were called in by the management company and all the remaining balconies in the development were propped up.
Alan Brewer, 60, one of the directors of the management company, says residents are taking legal action for £1.5 million to cover the cost of getting the balconies put right and to recover money they've already paid out.
Retired software engineer Mr Brewer, who paid £280,000 for his two-bedroom apartment in the Liberty Gardens building in 2002, believes problems arose because the cement boards were fixed to thin strips of wood called packers rather than wooden joists.
He said: "If one of the boards had come down on someone it would have been dangerous - it would probably kill someone.
"There have been a number of other problems as well as the soffits but we can't go into those because of the court case."
The Point, which was designed by Feilden Clegg Bradley and constructed by Skanska, won a string of awards in 2002 including the Building for Life awards from Cabe and a RIBA award.
Judges at the Housing Design Awards 2002 said: "There is a scale, sweep and assurance to this scheme which is all too rarely seen in private developments, and an attention to the quality of design extending from the internal planning to the treatment of the public realm, which makes it an excellent augury for the future."
A hearing has been set for next month at the Technology and Construction Court.
Crosby declined to comment. Skanska and FCB, which are not involved in the dispute, also made no comment.








23 Comments
View all
by Alan, Bristol City Centre
Monday, January 19 2009, 8:42PM
“Whatever your point of view - whether they should have been built or whether the buyers are looking to make a profit - builders should be responsible for the quality of their workmanship just in the same way as any other product. Hopefully the residents will win their case to make the builders responsible for a product which should not fall apart in only a few years!”
by Ben, Clifton
Sunday, January 18 2009, 5:38PM
“The flats AREN'T collapsing. Your headline is WRONG.”
by The Northsider, Gas Lane
Sunday, January 18 2009, 3:27PM
“Whats with the poetry?
Ok....Harold the Horny hunter had an enomous horn
!”
by Bob, Bristol
Sunday, January 18 2009, 2:39PM
“These appartments should never have been built . Maybee the eyesore will now be pulled down”
by Bristol, Bedminster, Bristol
Sunday, January 18 2009, 9:45AM
“Thanks Phil, isn¿t it funny how someone will always take the bait.”
by Andy, Xanadu
Saturday, January 17 2009, 11:41PM
“And all who heard should see them there,
And all should cry, Beware ! Beware !
His flashing eyes, his floating hair !
Weave a circle round him thrice,
And close your eyes with holy dread,
For he on honey-dew hath fed,
And drunk the milk of Paradise.
Samuel Taylor Coleridge
(From England by the way)”
by steven, germany
Saturday, January 17 2009, 6:56PM
“skanska sounds like a polish firm , it is the same all over europe,everyone is hiring cheap east european subcontractors to do their work . the standard of workmanship on construction in europe in the last 15yrs is terrible . You can hire the best name,s in the business to do the work , the problem is they don.t do the work some crap firm from who knowswhere doe,s it ,that is how everything works at the moment , its killing all the good firm,s and trades people off, You get what you pay for.”
by Andy, City Centre
Saturday, January 17 2009, 2:32PM
“Dudes,
Plenty of people get their mortgage paid by the council already. My nan lived in a council house for years and paid £5 a week maintenance. That was it.
If someone has worked hard and made sacrifices to buy somewhere nice to live then they deserve the right to live there without the place falling apart. It doesn't matter if you live in the harbour or clifton, kingsdown or henleaze.
Let the record show - The next time some low income family moans about being overlooked for essential repairs in their nice new home, 'rich people' get overlooked just as much too.
Call me old fashioned, but I don't see the difference. You pay for something, you deserve to get it as advertised. See contract law.”
by Andy P, Easton
Saturday, January 17 2009, 1:39PM
“"You'd like to think BCC would lend some support to residents in distress eh?"
You're having a laugh arn't you Andy? You'll be saying that the council should be paying their mortagages next! Where do you think that any money would come from? Our pockets that's where. As other people have pointed out, there's nothing luxury about the quality of materials or work in these flats. The buyers should have had the sense to get proper surveys done before they spent their cash.”
by Chris, Hotwells
Saturday, January 17 2009, 1:33PM
“Quote "They are only luxury flats because of the location, building materials are the same as any other site."
You got that spot on there Gerry.”