Bristol juror sex attacker handed supervision order

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, May 14, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

A juror who listened to a sex case and then carried out a sexual assault in Bristol while temporarily insane has been handed a 12 month supervision order.

Bristol Crown Court was told former soldier Alan Edwards had a history of mental health problems and had got himself excused from a child abuse case, only to serve as a juror in the trial of a sex assault on a teenage girl.

On the third day, suffering from "persecutionary delusions", he went to a city centre law firm and molested the receptionist when he was not in control of his actions.

Edwards, aged 58, of Portway, Shirehampton, pleaded not guilty to sexual assault in July last year, by reason of insanity.

A jury of seven men and five women unanimously returned a verdict that coincided with his plea.

Judge Simon Darwall-Smith said he "entirely agreed" with a recommendation to give Edwards the order. Edwards was told to sign on the Sex Offender's Register for five years.

Outside court Edwards, who was called for jury service again, seven years after being troubled as a juror previously, told the Bristol Evening Post: "When I was called again the first case I was on was a paedophilia case and they excused me.

"In the second case I thought I would be ok, but when I questioned it they said it was just the luck of the drawer. I think it should be done on a fairer basis."

The receptionist told the jury a man arrived at her premises and she thought he seemed to be acting odd.

She told the jury: "I said 'how can I help you?' and he looked at me and said 'Well, I've had a bad day'.

The woman described how the man sat on her desk and started reading company faxes, which she took from him.

When she asked if she could him again, he grabbed her and pulled her towards him.

She said: "He grabbed my hands rather firmly. He pulled me towards him, nuzzled his face in my neck and fondled my bottom with his hands. I started shouting 'No!, No!, Get off!' but he wasn't listening to anything I was saying.

"I got a hand free and as I pulled away he started grabbing between my legs. He was making groaning noises like he was enjoying what he was doing."

The court heard that, very quickly, office staff and clients arrived at the scene and pulled the man away.

The man identified himself as Alan Edwards to police who arrived at the scene, the court heard, but struggled and squealed during his arrest and had to be put in handcuffs and leg restraints and carried to a police van.

Edwards told police he felt as if he had been forced to do something against his will.

Rebecca Bradberry, defending, read a report by consultant psychiatrist Dr Caroline Bradley who noted Edwards suffered a road traffic accident in 1975, while in the army, and suffered a head injury.

Dr Bradley also noted Edwards was treated in a military hospital in 1993, then aged 42, after suffering a psychotic episode for which was successfully medicated.

The court heard Edwards had previously served as a juror in a paedophilia case which had caused him anxiety and odd behaviour.

Dr Bradley said Edwards told her that during his latest jury duty in July last year he had received a 1am phone call and felt someone was trying to get to him.

On the third day, at lunchtime, he thought he was going to be kidnapped and he walked to the law firm, sat down, put his head back and closed his eyes.

He said the next thing he remembered was being restrained on the floor and he had no memory of any offence.

Dr Bradley concluded Edwards was suffering psychotic symptoms, had feelings of being controlled and believed people were out to get him.

She said: "He could not know or control the nature or quality of his actions."

Dr Bradley's conclusion was backed up by consultant forensic psychiatrist Dr Tim Amos.

Miss Bradberry told the court: "Mr Edwards is extremely sorry for what happened."

The court heard Edwards had been prescribed medication and his family would be able to recognise tell-tale signs to ensure there was no re-occurrence of difficulties.

10
Tweet this article
Report

10 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by maggie, hartcliffe

    Thursday, May 14 2009, 11:00PM

    “it really doesnt matter wether the mental illness is caused by drugs or any other reason the end product is the same ,i have had many dealings with the mental health service *( or lack of it should i say ) with my son through drugs and now my husband because of an illness and the care and help us exactly the same for both its all too easy to see why mentally ill patients end up in court rooms and some for serious crimes ,i could write a book on this subject through my own experiences , in lots of cases its the mental health system that should be on trial and not the patients ,and before anybody comments i shouldnt be making excuses for these people unless you have lived with people with mental health problems you would be wiser to keep your opinions to yourself ,”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by John, Gloucestershire

    Thursday, May 14 2009, 6:32PM

    “Ok if hes not guilty by means of insanity then he should be sectioned!

    No problem with his defence but if people want to use the mental health card they should be in a secure hospital for longer than what the criminal custodial sentence would have been.

    You also have to question the criteria for jury service!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Kirsty, Horfield

    Thursday, May 14 2009, 3:35PM

    “Perhaps, instead of blowing every offence out of proportion when the word ¿sex¿ is involved, people should start having some perspective. Maybe we should save the powerful wrath of the state for those who are truly deserving ¿ such as rapists, actual paedophiles, those who calculate to defraud the vulnerable, etc. This man has been mentally ill for over 30 years and has clearly been neglected by a society that doesn¿t want to accept that mental illness is a problem which damages the lives of ordinary people. Perhaps instead of reigning down your supreme, vindictive judgment upon this man ¿Mike¿, you should try to understand him and attempt to help him and others like him. I¿m sure that would take too much effort though. Who knows ¿ maybe one day you¿ll suffer from mental illness and will change your somewhat clichéd tune.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Dale, St George

    Thursday, May 14 2009, 3:12PM

    “If this had been my mum or sister the guy would have ended up in a hospital - hope someone knocks on his door.
    He will reoffend and play the mental health card trick again.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Mike, Bristol

    Thursday, May 14 2009, 2:08PM

    “What an insult to the victim, do these judges come from another planet.

    Start punishing people for crimes, don't keep letting them off.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article