Bristol girl misses out of school place after council draws straws
Bristol education chiefs at the city council had to resort to drawing straws over the future of two children who live in the same tower block, but will go to different primary schools.
Briana Welling is a victim of the school places lottery in Bristol as she has missed out on getting into the reception class at Fairfurlong Primary in Withywood.
-
Becky Kane with daughter Briana
Another child in the same block of flats has been given a place.
Bristol City Council has confirmed lots had to be drawn to decide whether Briana or the other child, who both live in Rowan House in Hartcliffe, should be allocated a place for September – and Briana had lost.
She and her mum Becky Kane live in a 10th floor flat in the block on Bishport Avenue. Although there are other schools close to their home, Ms Kane wanted her daughter to go to her old primary school and got Briana into the nursery class at Fairfurlong last September.
"I was shocked when I got the letter from the council to say that my daughter and one other were the only ones in the class who hadn't got a place in reception," said Ms Kane, 24.
"All my family went to Fairfurlong and I wanted Briana to go there. My little brother Simon, who's nine, is still a pupil at the school."
Ms Kane, a single mum, works full time as a health care assistant and her father Colin, who lives off Hareclive Road, takes Briana to school along with Simon.
She must now wait until April to find out if any places become available at Fairfurlong, which was oversubscribed.
If they do not, she will be offered a place at the nearest school to her home that has vacancies. The family has the right of appeal.
Places are granted according to criteria set out in Bristol City Council's guidance for parents.
Children in care get priority, followed by siblings of current pupils and then it goes to the closest to the school.
The guidance states: "Nursery class attendance is not taken into account when places are allocated for reception."
It also says: "Where two or more children live in a flat or other multi-home dwelling and it is not possible to determine which applicant lives closest to the preferred school as measured in a direct line from the building to the school, the available place or places will be allocated by drawing lots."
Council spokeswoman Katharine de Lisle said: "Briana was unlucky in that she and another child from the same block applied for places at Fairfurlong and it did come down to random allocation.
"With regard to the family member at Fairfurlong, we are unable to consider that under the sibling rule because Briana does not live in the same household as her uncle."
She said the council had received 89 applications for the 45 places available at the school for September.
More than 300 families across the city failed to win places for their children at any of their preferred primary schools and must now wait until April before finding out where they will be allocated.







14 Comments
View all
by Erm, Are you not missing the point
Tuesday, February 10 2009, 9:39PM
“Why are you fighting for this "amazing" school ? It did nothing for your spelling, punctuation or grammar !? Send them to another school and get them a decent education, one hopefully better than yours.”
by janet, bristol
Tuesday, February 10 2009, 12:31PM
“jade my advice to you. is to fight for a place for your daughter. the city council should put things back the way they where in the first place. if your child attends the nusery they should go straught on to reception .the city council should not pick children out of a hat to say who will get a place or not .we dont wont any child to be taken out for briana .they have 45 children going up to reception 2 classes why cant they put 23 in one class 24 in the other to make room for your child and briana.in my sons class there is 25 so i dont see how they can say it would be to meny.”
by jade, hartcliffe
Tuesday, February 10 2009, 11:49AM
“as colleen have said children who goes to that nursery should have priority so briana and my daughter should have priority to that school seeming they went to nursery there, not other chilren who didnt!!!”
by Chris, Bristle
Tuesday, February 10 2009, 9:08AM
“So, which other child are you going to take out of this school to enable Briana to go there?
Or would you prefer overcrowded classes, I'm sure that would get on the front page of the EP.”
by janet, bristol
Tuesday, February 10 2009, 12:16AM
“a comment for that teacher. school is ment to be the happiest time in a child life . and briana is happy at that school .to take her out now would unsetle her .if a child is unhappy in a school the child dosnt wont to go to school.”
by janet, bristol
Tuesday, February 10 2009, 12:06AM
“i am brianas grandmother.the reson my daughter is fighting to get a place for briana in that school is because we take briana to school for my daughter to work to keep her and her daughter.what would you rather my daughter pack her job up and be yet another single mum on the dole. i dont think so .”
by Chris, Bristle
Monday, February 09 2009, 10:37PM
“As well as free education, she is being taught in classes that are not too large.”
by jade, hartcliffe
Monday, February 09 2009, 7:41PM
“life is about giving your kids the best, if you got kids then you should understand!!!”
by Chris, Bristle
Monday, February 09 2009, 5:49PM
“Yes Jade, you want it. As I said, you can't always have it. Welcome to life.”
by colleen, hartcliffe
Monday, February 09 2009, 5:47PM
“as a parent myself i think its unfair to take a child out of a school that they have gone to for the last year through no choice of there own if the goverment is saying the child lives to far away why give them a place at that nursery in the first place personally if ur child attends that nursery they should get priority to go to that primary school”