Bristol cancer patient's parking reprieve

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

A single mum from Bristol has been promised a full refund after she was given a parking fine while having chemotherapy for breast cancer.

Allison Veale, 42, who lives in Kingswood, paid £3 for a 45-minute ticket at Bristol Oncology Centre's car park in Kingsdown.

But the 30-minute procedure overran as doctors took four attempts to insert a line into her arm.

When she finally came out at 11am, she found a £60 fine on the windscreen, put there at 10.08am – 23 minutes after the ticket expired.

The family paid the fine on the same day, cutting the cost to £30, but they are furious it was given in the first place and have appealed.

The NHS trust which owns the car park has now promised a full refund.

Allison, who is a full-time mum to Byron, 11, said: "I think it is disgusting. When you are going to hospital for cancer treatment you don't want any extra worries, just to get it done and go home to bed.

"The last thing I had on my mind was the car. I was so worried about having the procedure that I put £3 in and thought it would cover it.

"That would pay for a couple of hours at Frenchay Hospital. I was furious when I saw the fine."

Allison is worried about future costs. She said: "I can't afford £60 as a single mum. I had to go back for chemotherapy the following day and put in £5, which is a lot of money every time. I have to go every three weeks, and in December will have to have radium every day. It will cost me a fortune.

"I feel like writing a sign and putting it in the window next time – 'having chemotherapy, please understand'. It is appalling, really."

Allison's mum, Caroline, 67, said: "It is disgusting that we have to pay for parking. They know that people are there for cancer treatment. I don't know how they can sleep at night."

Allison's call for a refund was backed by Duleep Allirajah, policy manager for Macmillan Cancer Support. He said: "They shouldn't have been charged in the first place, and the hospital should have a policy in place that gives regular visitors for cancer or radiotherapy reduced parking charges, in accordance with Department of Health guidelines.

"We believe patients undergoing treatment for cancer should be exempt from all hospital parking charges.

"An average cancer patient spends over £300 a year paying hospital parking fees – an extra cost they can ill afford as they cope with the stress of cancer. It is basically a tax on illness."

Adrian Ruck, spokesman for University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, which owns the car park, said: "We are sorry to learn that Allison Veale was upset by the parking ticket she received after a visit to our hospital.

"At our city centre site it is vitally important that we manage our parking to ensure that only patients are offered the use of our facilities.

"As with all cases like this, Allison will be fully refunded and we apologise for any inconvenience.

"For those of our patients who need to return frequently for treatment, we keep parking charges at a minimum.

"Patients only pay for the first hour of parking, which is then free for the rest of the week."

At UHBristol, patients who are regularly spending a lot of time in hospital can buy a ticket that will enable them to park for up to a week for the price of the lowest standard fee.

The patient or driver can swap their £2.20 ticket for the long-term parking pass on their ward.

At North Bristol NHS Trust there is no scheme in place for patients coming in for regular treatment, but they are advised to speak to a nurse in their ward or unit, who may be able to make arrangements with the on-site parking services team.

Free hospital parking was brought in at Welsh hospitals in April this year and last month the Scottish parliament made the decision to bring in free parking from January 1.

13
Tweet this article
Report

13 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Tracey, Bristol

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 6:57PM

    “To Jojo: The main difference is: you chose to have a baby - she did not choose to have cancer. You knew how much bringing up a child costs, and presumably could afford it. If you have cancer, you may also lose your job, and therefore your income.
    And as regards the blue badge, if your mother didn't apply for it, thats her fault. She would probably be entitled, as its based on how far you can walk. (and I'm guessing she couldn't walk far if she was having radiotherapy, as it makes you very tired)”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by JoJo, Bristol

    Wednesday, October 15 2008, 8:19AM

    “Tracey not everyone is entitled to get free parking. My mother had radiotherapy for breast cancer and paid parking charges every day she was there. What I am saying is that why should some patients have free parking and others not? It should be all patients get it or none, it shouldn't depend on the treatment you are having.
    By the way, when I had my daughter you could not get a free pass for parking, we paid. And didn't quibble either. I was actually in hospital with complications in delivery (life threatening complications for me and baby) from 1am until 11.30am the following day. Every penny was paid for parking.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Tracey, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 9:25PM

    “If you are having cancer treatment, you are usually entitled to a blue parking badge, due to the fact that you are usually not able to walk very far. Therefore you would be entitled to free parking, and able to park on some double yellow lines. You may also be entitled to claim disability/mobility allowance to assist you with parking charges.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Alex, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 9:19PM

    “"Opie", 2 points:

    1. Thanks for supporting my comments about how difficult (and futile) it would be to determine the priority of patients visiting ANY hospital for treatment. And, yes you're right, in this particular NHS unit, even more so.

    2. Whilst I obviously support cycling and try to educate others in the advantages of such over car-driving across the board - socially, economically and environmentally. I think demanding that patients with terminal cancer to cycle to their hospital for treatment would be ridiculous, even for you to assume that this would be something I'd post as a comment.. Get real.

    Good retort, though.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Opie, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 7:23PM

    “Alex, by definition the vast majority of people attending for treatment at an ONCOLOGY centre will be critical.

    I'm impressed you haven't told them to cycle in to be honest, given the standard and agenda of your usual posts”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by me, bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 6:32PM

    “JoJo well done for paying for your parking, but if you or your birthing partner had asked you would have been given a free pass for the time you were in labour! better luck next time.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Alex, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 5:45PM

    “I think Jojo just likes to disagree with people for fun...

    Anyways, it would be incredibly difficult to monitor which cars belong to patients receiving treatment. And how would you factor in the priority of parking over how critical the treatment is?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Donna, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 4:19PM

    “You are right again JoJo! I'm sure she'll think harder about having cancer again in the future!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by JoJo, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 4:12PM

    “What I am saying is, why should it be one rule for one and one for the other? Parking charges are there to be paid so they should be paid by whoever uses the car park. Not rocket science is it?”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Donna, Bristol

    Tuesday, October 14 2008, 4:01PM

    “Maria, Anyone who is a regular reader of these columns would soon realise that JoJo has compasson for no one - not even cancer sufferers!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters