Bristol ambulance took 30 minutes to travel 3 miles

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, October 08, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

A series of failings meant it took the ambulance service 30 minutes to travel just three miles to reach a Bristol heart attack patient, an inquest heard.

Retired teacher John Eickhoff, 71, was left waiting for medical help at The Mall, Cribbs Causeway, when he collapsed in his car.

The inquest at Flax Bourton heard a rapid responder should have been there in five minutes after being dispatched from the Shield Retail Park in Filton but took 30 minutes to arrive on October 13 last year.

The hearing was told Mark Braddock, who was working for an agency used by Great Western Ambulance Service, was not familiar with the Bristol area and encountered problems with his satellite navigation system.

The Welshman was sent down a closed road twice, had to pull over to call a control centre and ended up reaching Cribbs Causeway via the M5 before driving into the wrong car park at The Mall, the inquest was told.

Coroner Anthony Woodburn heard that when ambulance technician Mr Braddock arrived he initially pulled out an oxygen mask designed for child because he could not find one for an adult.

And when he attached a defibrillator to the pensioner, he discovered he was dead.

Mr Woodburn was told a paramedic did not reach Mr Eickhoff until 14 minutes after Mr Braddock arrived - 44 minutes after the 999 call was made.

However, a pathologist said Mr Eickhoff's heart failure was so severe he wouldn't have been saved by a swift response.

The inquest heard GWAS aimed to get a rapid responder to Category A, or life-threatening, calls within eight minutes and an ambulance and paramedic there within 19 minutes.

Mr Eickhoff's widow Sue, 67, who lived with him in Kingswood, said she hoped lessons had been learned from the failings.

She said: "I hope they don't make those mistakes again. The ambulance service says it has corrected some of their procedures now and I hope their systems have changed."

Mrs Eickhoff's daughter Philippa Ficuciello, 43, who lives in Fishponds, said: "We know he couldn't be saved and wouldn't have suffered but this inquest might save somebody else's life if procedures are put in place."

The inquest heard Mr Braddock was employed by an ambulance trust in Wales and also as a rapid responder for Aztec West-based Evolved Medical Services, which was used by Great Western Ambulance Service for emergency response calls.

Andrew Parker, head of controls at GWAS, said problems Mr Eickhoff had experienced with his satellite navigation system had been rectified since the incident.

Recording a verdict of death by natural causes, Mr Woodburn said: "He (Mr Eickhoff) wasn't affected substantially by the failures we have heard about.

"It must be of some comfort to Mrs Eickhoff that she won't have to live with the prospect of blame for her husband's departure."

13
Tweet this article
Report

13 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Suzie, Bristol

    Thursday, October 08 2009, 9:21PM

    “A while ago my Mum woke up with heart palpitations and stuff, so phone NHS direct who then phoned her an ambulance. The rapid response team turned up within 5 minutes, the ambulance arrived within 10. Which considering we're quite far from any ambulance stations was quite impressive.

    I've never had any problem with the NHS. I think it's FAB!!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Mark, Bristol

    Thursday, October 08 2009, 8:00PM

    “Errr... Bob. Hang on, you called an EMERGENCY ambulance because your girlfriend had had a drink? Surely, if you girlfriend could have taken you to hospital, you could have phoned a taxi or got someone else to take you? The reason we have problems getting to genuine patients is because of people like you using us a taxi service.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Steve, Bristol

    Thursday, October 08 2009, 7:54PM

    “I was at one of the bike/lorry disasters this summer -not involved as the bike or driver-. The paramedics were there in 3 minutes
    ambulance from the BRI came within 6, and they brought the doctor who goes out on helicopter calls too.

    What happened here sounds like the system relied on SatNav to get people to where they were going, not realising that SatNav fails. The maps are always out of date, sometimes even the satellites play up. It's one thing to use SatNav to find your way to a friends house, another to rely on it to get you to a patient if you don't know the way.

    As somone who is certified to use a defibrillator @work, I believe that the best way to save someone's life is not for the ambulance to come in less than 10 minute, it is for Cribb's to have a defib unit to hand. Did they? That is one thing that could have made a difference. CPR until defib, and defib within a couple of minutes of the "heart attack" -that's the action which has an outcome.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by bob, bristol

    Thursday, October 08 2009, 6:34PM

    “just like to say however the actual paramedics/docs/nurses were great :o)”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by bob, bristol

    Thursday, October 08 2009, 6:33PM

    “There media only ever highlight the odd bad story. However i had cause for an ambulance last week. Nothing major but need checking out and couldn't get to a&e owing to gf having had a drink after work so called 999 and within 2-3 mins a prapid response car turned up and paramedic checked me out. i was fine but she said to go to bri for a check to be safe but then had to wait 45mins for a "proper" ambulance to turn up because the ones that weren't busy were on their break. i wasn't a priority but it is a bit annoying being told you have to wait because they are having their cuppa or whatever. No doubt in an emergency they would drop their tea and come help???”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article