Bristol MP's £169 toaster claim 'reasonable'
Kingswood MP Roger Berry spent £15,000 kitting out his two-bed townhouse with luxury items including a £169 toaster, £979 television and a £1,000 washer dryer.
Mr Berry, a Labour backbencher, claimed the money over four years to spend on his second home in Southwark, London, the Post can reveal today.
-

Mr Berry, whose Bristol ward is one of the less prosperous in the city, also claimed for £3,425 of building works, £1,880 towards decorating his lounge and spent £2,264 on carpets.
Between 2004 and 2008 he submitted £999 worth of claims for furnishing, including four for the amount of £159 to cover monthly payments towards the cost of two sofas.
Under the rules governing second home expenses, MPs are not allowed to make purchases which would be deemed "extravagant or luxurious".
Mr Berry last night denied that he had behaved unreasonably.
He said: "The toaster is not an all-singing, all-dancing one – it's a type that will last for at least 10 years instead of something that won't last.
"The washing machine is an environmentally-friendly type which is also built to last.
"I don't think that the money paid for decorating the lounge is unreasonable.
"Unfortunately, those are the kind of prices that you have to pay in London these days."
He said the claims submitted to the fees office were not regarded as excessive.
He said that if they had thought they were, then the fees office would have queried the claims with him.
Mr Berry said he did not think that he had behaved unreasonably in relation to his second home which he has described as a "modest two bedroom townhouse". It has a living room downstairs and two bedrooms and bathroom upstairs.
His typical monthly expenses claim includes mortgage interest of around £960, £300 for food and £50 for utility bills.
Mr Berry published the receipts on his website ahead of their official release by the House of Commons next month.
MPs are allowed to claim back money for the cost of having to run two homes, which can cover mortgage or rent, bills, furniture and repairs among other things.
He told the Post: "I moved in to a new place in October 2003.
"The decorating costs were to get it sorted out and the building work was for a new boiler because the old one collapsed.
"My claims have dropped significantly because once these things have been bought it doesn't have to be bought again.
"There was substantial set up costs.
"I believe that I have been reasonable but I think there should be a completely independent group of people that go through every MP's expenses. They should have the power to order MPs to pay back anything they think is unreasonable and if they decided any of mine were, I would gladly do that.
"MPs have to have two places to live.
"If we didn't enable MPs to have a second home, that would mean only the rich could do the job.
"I don't think my constituents think I live in a country mansion, they know that I live in Fishponds and that is my main home.
"But so many people have been exposed that they might think we are all in the same category. It is hurtful but that is part of the turf.
"I supported the Freedom of Information Act and it is precisely to ensure that people behave properly.
"We might find it a bit embarrassing but that is life."
His claims for the last financial year under the Additional Costs Allowance came in at £14,717 – about 60 per cent of the maximum allowed.







63 Comments
View all
by Sammy, Bristol
Tuesday, May 26 2009, 11:53PM
“Let's not forget to be objective here people, look at the facts and not the emotive language and details of B grade journalism. Yes, £169 for a toaster is far-fetched but look at the overall amount claimed by Roger Berry and his expenses are nowhere near as extravagant as certain newspaper articles would have us believe. Remember that the media make the stories and with surprisingly little effort they can demonise anyone or anything if it happens to be the run of the day. I would just like to say that anyone who has been fortunate to have any contact with Roger Berry will know he's an excellent MP who has demonstrated high levels of integrity both at Westminster and within the constituency. As many people have rightly stated, he has repeatedly stood up for many important issues and has an outsatnding track record when it comes to responding to the concerns of his constituents. To anyone who has rashly decided never to vote for Dr Berry again because of this "£169" expense claim, I would respectfully suggest they look at the overall picture. Thanks”
by Robert, Swindon
Monday, May 25 2009, 8:44AM
“A 6 slice Dualite Commercial Toaster costs less than £100. The one above must be gold plated.”
by Richard, Bristol
Sunday, May 24 2009, 9:25PM
“It's over the top claiming this for a toaster but I wouldn't wish it on anyone having to live in London for too long.
The problem with winning Sir Alan's Apprentice is having to live here and MP's unfortunately have to live here as well.
It's time for you to spend more time in Fishponds Mr Berry, help tidy up the area.”
by Ali, Bristol
Sunday, May 24 2009, 9:18PM
“It will be reasonable for me NOT to vote for this man in the forthcoming local elections. Bye bye Mr Berry (former MP) lol”
by Hog, bristol
Sunday, May 24 2009, 6:12PM
“If it was a Dualit, then good on him, they're made in London, thus creating UK manufacturing jobs”
by Phil, Downend, Bristol
Sunday, May 24 2009, 4:06PM
“Most of us who live in Kingswood - whatever our political leanings - know how hard Roger Berry works for his constituents, and that is why he has our support.
The total of his expenses claims are far smaller than many MPs. It's hard to imagine this kind of story getting traction in a country like the United States where they would have a little more appreciation for a person who has spent two decades serving his constituents.”
by Carl, Bromley Heath
Sunday, May 24 2009, 2:27PM
“Its quite an expensive bit of equipment for toasting bread! But the rest isnt over the top. Most people I know who replace their main tv spend £7-800 upwards for a good lcd”
by Mikey, Henleaze
Sunday, May 24 2009, 2:10PM
“I think Jay was a bit drunk- look at the times he was posting at! Odd. Anyway I agree with some of Soarers points. MPs do get a hard time, some deservedly. But I wouldnt want to do that job for that salary without some good perks! And technically the brother who stole the £1 is worse than most MPs. He was breaking the companies rules on expenses- most MP's were not. I dont think the expenses in most cases were unreasonable- certainly not Roger Berrys. the duck house was taking the p*** though!”
by Michael, Clifton
Sunday, May 24 2009, 11:57AM
“Can some kind person please translate the semi-illiterate ramblings of the person called "Jay" I would so like to obtain a view from the as it were, underclass, on this subject.
Thanks”
by Blueblood, Bristol
Sunday, May 24 2009, 10:43AM
“Berry is a freeloader just like all of his so called 'socialist' cronies at the labour party,but dont worry Roger,general election just a year away so make the most of it,because your gona have plenty of time on your hands for gardening etc.”