Bristol’s 42 crossings – not a bridge too far for maths ace

Trusted article source icon
Friday, March 01, 2013
Profile image for DavidClensy

DavidClensy

David Clensy meets the Bristol University mathematician who challenged himself to cross all of Bristol’s bridges - going over each one just once

CROSSING seven bridges doesn’t sound like the most taxing challenge. But crossing seven bridges when you’re only allowed to cross the bridges once, in one direction, was a mathematical problem that challenged the greatest minds in the Prussian town of Königsberg in the 18th century.

  1. drthilogross

    Dr Thilo Gross

  2. drthilogrossmap

    Dr Thilo Gross' map of Bristol's bridges

When mathematician Dr Thilo Gross arrived in Bristol a year-and-a-half ago to take up his new post teaching engineering mathematics at Bristol University, he soon noticed that his new home had some notable geographical likenesses to Königsberg.

But while Königsberg had seven bridges and two islands of land caught between two rivers, Bristol had three such “islands” – Spike Island, St Philip’s and Redcliffe – and it had a more taxing 42 formal bridges that could be crossed by foot.

Dyson DC50i - Bagless upright vacuum cleaner - BALL Technology -...

Freenet Electrical Ltd

View details

Thisi is Dyson's smallest upright vacuum cleaner with the performance of a full size upright machine. The DC50i has Dyson's most advanced cleaner head technology and 2 Tier RadialTM cyclones.

Terms: LIMITED STOCK OFFER. FREE delivery to most UK postcodes - Next working day dispatch.

Contact: 01664 491439

Valid until: Monday, May 27 2013

“I came here to Bristol because it was one of the best places in the world in terms of my own particular specialism – network mathematics,” he says.

“That’s essentially what the Königsberg bridge problem is – it’s all about understanding the mathematics of networks.

“I teach the problem to all my students, so when I realised it could be done here in Bristol, I couldn’t resist trying to work it out.”

It took Dr Gross a fortnight with a pen, a map and countless screwed up and discarded pieces of paper – but eventually he worked out his solution.

But rather than leaving it as an academic puzzle, he couldn’t resist putting on his walking boots and taking to the streets of the city for himself – even though completing the route would mean a 33 mile walk.

“It was a very long day,” he tells me, as he recovers from his self-inflicted trial by rambling, a few days after his very long walk.

“It took me more than 12 hours to complete the walk – but it was absolutely worth it when I stepped over the finishing line at Clifton Suspension Bridge. To be honest I never thought I’d be able to complete the walk until the very moment when I walked over the Avon Gorge.”

Eventually mathematician Leonhard Euler proved that the problem for Königsberg has no solution.

In the history of mathematics, Euler’s negative solution of the Königsberg bridge problem in 1735 is considered to be the first theorem of graph theory – a discipline without which much modern computer science would be impossible.

His treatment led to the birth of the branch of maths known as discrete mathematics, and by extension modern day network science that is relevant to a wide range of application areas from the running of the internet to controlling epidemics.

So for Dr Gross to be able to demonstrate to his students how here in Bristol the problem can be solved, was something of a “eureka!” moment for him.

“The key is to understand first and foremost how you are going to cross from each island to the next without trapping yourself,” Dr Gross explains.

“My initial plan had me starting my walk in Bedminster, but I quickly realised I cornered myself – especially when I discovered that Bristol had a bridge I didn’t know about.

“It is a small railway bridge near Temple Meads railway station, which to my amazement had a small footpath running alongside it.”

The discovery of that one bridge sent Dr Gross back to the drawing board.

“There is nothing intuitive about this problem,” he says. “It’s not that you start at one end and work your way neatly to the other – it’s far more complex than that, and this is why it takes 33 miles of walking.”

He eventually started his walk at Spike Island, criss-crossing back and forth along the bridges of the New Cut in an easterly direction, before looping back around the Temple Quarter, across Bristol Bridge, Pero’s Bridge and Avon Bridge before tackling Plimsoll Bridge and walking to Sea Mills and then Avonmouth Bridge, before returning back on the North Somerset side of the river and crossing the final bridge – Brunel’s Clifton Suspension Bridge.

“There will be other ways to do it,” he says. “But I particularly wanted to finish the day with the best known bridge in the city.”

In fact, the mathematical treatment showed that ending the walk with the suspension bridge was not possible until recently, when a new footbridge was built behind Temple Meads Station.

The solution of the bridge problem, may not be a great mathematical discovery, but Gross says it was a great personal achievement.

“In a city with a name – Brycstow – that means ‘place of the bridge’ and which has a bridge as its major landmark, I just had to do it,” he says.

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for katachua

    by katachua

    Sunday, March 03 2013, 2:36PM

    “This article explains the Konigsberg problem rather well http://tinyurl.com/y8lx46

  • Profile image for ogeron

    by ogeron

    Friday, March 01 2013, 11:51PM

    “A very rare article for the Evening Post in that it doesn't treat its readers as idiots. I didn't understand much after the first few sentences myself but still enjoyed it immensely. Now if Dr Gross could turn his attention to our public transport network and make it possible to get a bus between any two points in Bristol without having to go to the Centre first he will be on to a winner.”

  • Profile image for 78787

    by 78787

    Friday, March 01 2013, 4:18PM

    “2 weeks to solve it? I think Dr Gross is exaggerating the problem to make himself look clever. Once the bridges and land masses have been reduced to paths and nodes it is instantly possible to see in the network is traversable (and indeed whether it is traversable and can finish at the same place as the journey begins). Bristol and its bridges are a semi-Eulerian network and there are many algorithms that can be used to solve it. In addition there are only two possible starting points - those land masses that have an odd number of paths leading to them.

    2 weeks? Rubbish - I have just recreated the network in half 40minutes. It'll take about 20 mins using an algorithm to find the path.”

  • Profile image for Lone_Ranger

    by Lone_Ranger

    Friday, March 01 2013, 12:52PM

    “"mathematician Leonhard Euler proved that the problem for Königsberg has no solution...So for Dr Gross to be able to demonstrate to his students how here in Bristol the problem can be solved, was something of a "eureka!" moment for him."

    Rubbish - there was nothing to be solved in Bristol because the "problem" of Königsberg never existed here in the first place.”

  • Profile image for PJ1979

    by PJ1979

    Friday, March 01 2013, 12:46PM

    “@FromMendip

    If you walk through Castle Park you can see that they have created the opening in the side of one of the old brewery buildings ready to install the Mobius bridge. The scheme is progressing very slowly in phases, but I believe it will happen.

    Other locations calling out for a footbridge are:
    1) King Street to Redcliffe Street, they have plenty of S106 money for this, but suspect it has been given back.
    2) Beauley Road to Spike island. thsi combined with the next one, would really icrease walking (Park street to Southville in 15 minutes)
    3) SS Great Britain to Anchor Road
    4) M Shed to Lloyds Amphitheatre

    Perhaps the last two could be addressed via ferry crossings?”

  • Profile image for FromMendip

    by FromMendip

    Friday, March 01 2013, 12:01PM

    “Speaking of Bristol bridges, waht's happening about the Mobius Bridge?

    It was supposed to be a spectacular structure joining Finzel's Reach and Castle Park. A good proportion of Finzel's Reach now seems to have been developed with no obvious work currently taking place.

    Will the bridge go the same way as the section 106 payments for the site?”

  • Profile image for GrumbleDuke

    by GrumbleDuke

    Friday, March 01 2013, 11:48AM

    “He is obviously brilliant to have found something that doesn't exist, as you suggest 'shroom. It's people like Thilo, who find wonder in the mundane, that help drive civilization forward. Nice one Doc.”

  • Profile image for Young_Ron

    by Young_Ron

    Friday, March 01 2013, 11:34AM

    “Due to the redrawing of the map of Europe by 2 world wars in the 20th century, Königsberg has moved from Germany to Russia and is now known as Kaliningrad.”

  • Profile image for A_Mushroom

    by A_Mushroom

    Friday, March 01 2013, 10:53AM

    “Academics, eh? Finding a challenge where one does not really exist. Could he solve the problem of finding his own backside without the aid of a map?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article