Bristol City's Ashton Gate Tesco battle 'winnable'

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, May 30, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

Plans for a Tesco supermarket at Ashton Gate are "very winnable on planning grounds" according to a leading Bristol expert.

The verdict will be music to the ears of City fans and the club, who desperately want to see a new store at the site of the ground to help fund a new stadium.

The Post understands that some council officers and politicians are against the idea of another supermarket in the area because of the impact on local shops.

But Mike Orr, from Bristol-based CSJ Planning, said: "I think there is a very powerful planning argument in favour of Tesco going on this site.

"It's a development that would stimulate the local economy, it would not be so far away from a town centre to cause serious damage, it would help to improve local transport and it would help to regenerate the area."

Mr Orr has worked on many high-profile and controversial planning issues in the city for years.

He said that under planning guidance, there are two tests which must be passed before consent for a store can be given.

First, it must be demonstrated there is a need for the store and, second, it must be shown what damage, if any, would be caused to an existing town centre (North Street).

Mr Orr said the need could be shown because Sainsbury's has had to expand recently to cope with soaring demand and thousands of homes are expected to be built in nearby Ashton Vale during the next 15 years.

On the impact to existing shops, Mr Orr said he believed that many people who live in the North Street area prefer to shop in independently-run outlets and others from a wider area enjoy the convenience of a supermarket but choose to buy some items, such as meat, bread and fish, from specialist shops.

"The impact of a new supermarket on North Street is going to be a big battleground and nobody can gaze into a crystal ball and say whether it's going to have a positive or a negative effect," he said.

"But North Street is being regenerated by independent traders and attracting a customer profile that wants individual shops.

"If they were not doing this, then they would be going to Sainsbury's."

For these reasons, Mr Orr thought it was unlikely that Tesco would "undermine the function of North Street".

In fact, he believes that Tesco will argue that a new supermarket would help anchor shopping trends in the area.

"With a retail development of this type, the planning guidance says they should be built in town centres and if that is not possible, then they should at least be on the edge, which is recognised to be within 300 metres of the town centre," added Mr Orr.

He said this policy was drawn up because supermarkets in town centres encouraged shoppers to use local shops.

"The first test is whether the store would be within 300 metres of North Street and the answer is that it's about 550-600 metres," said Mr Orr.

"In planning terms, therefore, this does not quite meet the test but it is definitely achievable."

He said this was partly because there was no alternative site which was nearer to the North Street shops.

Another major factor in winning planning permission was the prospect of World Cup football in the city.

A new store would be the key link in funding a new 30,000-seat stadium at nearby Ashton Vale.

Club chairman Steve Lansdown told the Post that redevelopment of Ashton Gate was crucial to the funding of the new stadium.

12
Tweet this article
Report

12 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by A Local Resident, Bedminster

    Monday, June 01 2009, 12:56PM

    “I think the addition of Tesco on the site of Ashton Gate would be great for the locals giving more freedom of choice and also lots more jobs which is a good thing.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by PJ, Brislington

    Monday, June 01 2009, 10:11AM

    “Clearly this Tesco application falls the first of Mr Orr's tests.

    If Sainsburys has just expanded that will have been to meet demand, not so demand will reduce, not increase!

    So why is there need for a whole new store? Thousands of houses at Ashton Vale? If Mr Orr actually looked at the Plans for Ashton Vale he would see that the majority of these are located near the A38/woodspring golf club and the development will have it own High Street.

    If the need for a new Tesco is due to the Houses at Ashton Park then the new Tesco should be located within the new development, not miles down the road!

    APPLICATION REFUSED”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by il raderiono, cesena

    Sunday, May 31 2009, 2:38PM

    “can we please have an end to the phrase 'end of'? It means nothing!! end of.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by steven, Nuremburg

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 5:08PM

    “What about the DANDY ???”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by david, Planet Earth

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 4:37PM

    “76% of people want the Tesco store according to the poll conducted by the evening post.

    End of.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Dave, Bristle

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 4:20PM

    “I'd agree the beano is far more relevant and up to date.

    the last thing we need is ANOTHER supermarket. end of.

    It will be up to the council to not give in to tescos and there supreme 'buying power' and say NO.

    End of.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by gaz, bristol

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 3:53PM

    “joe, that's my whole point, this story is not "unfolding". The e.p just "report" the same stuff EVERY SINGLE DAY!
    There is nothing different in today's "report" that was in Mondays "report".”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by steve, bristol

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 3:05PM

    “I agree Gaz, it's now overtaken the M.P's expenses exposure as the bore of the moment,and I don't read about it, pass me Beano mum!!”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Joe, Bristol

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 11:53AM

    “Gaz,what sort of idiot are you,its the job of a local paper to report on events,or storys as they unfold,thats exactly what the BEP is doing,if you don't want to read about what is happening in the area,buy the Beano.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Peter, Bristol

    Saturday, May 30 2009, 10:57AM

    “I agree with the comment that Tesco will be needed when the homes are built at Ashton Vale.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters