Anger over closure of south Bristol walk-in health centre
People in south Bristol are angry that a walk-in health centre in Knowle West is to close.
The flagship centre at Knowle West Health Park was one of the first in the country when it opened in September 2000.
-

Local people were involved in the design of the health park and were delighted that they could be treated for minor ailments and injuries in the evenings and at weekends.
But NHS Bristol says the walk-in centre will close once the new South Bristol Community Hospital is built in Hengrove Park and there will be a walk-in clinic there instead.
Statistics show that people living in Knowle West have poorer health than the rest of the city – life expectancy is, on average, 10 years less than in other areas.
Users of the health park say the walk-in centre at the community hospital should be "as well as, not instead of" the one in Downton Road.
Rose Manning, chairwoman of Knowle West Health Park, fears the transfer of facilities could be the thin end of the wedge.
A cafe in the same building is to close on December 23. People who go to exercise, art, child health and complementary therapy groups all meet there.
A recent exhibition on plans for the regeneration of Knowle West showed the health park shaded in yellow – where housing is planned.
Urban Initiatives, the consultant which drew up the plans, denied that homes were planned on the large site but said there would be changes.
Mrs Manning said: "The health park only opened nine years ago. There are a lot of services here, the William Budd Health Centre, the dialysis unit and the cafe, as well as the walk-in centre.
"It is on a large site. Some people, but not local people, would like to see much of this turned into housing.
"People have been asked if they would be prepared to give up 50 per cent of the health park in return for other things they would like to see. Local people are not prepared to give up the health park."
It may be a few years before the walk-in clinic transfers to Hengrove Park, because the foundations have not yet been laid for the £54 million South Bristol Community Hospital.
The 60-bed hospital was originally supposed to have been finished by the autumn of this year. That target was then put back to early next year but NHS Bristol, which is responsible for health spending in the city, now says it is aiming for construction work to be completed by 2012.
Ben Bennett, Associate Director of Strategic Development NHS Bristol, said: "The PCT has developed plans to commission outpatient clinics for children which will operate from the space released by the transfer of the walk-in centre.
"Previously the PCT undertook a specific engagement exercise with local people in Knowle West to consider what factors were felt to be important in identifying alternative uses for the walk-in centre space.
"The feedback from local people indicated a strong preference for community health services for children and families. There is still some considerable time before services move out of the walk-in centre once the new hospital has been built.
"The details of the specific clinics which will be offered will be confirmed nearer to the time of the planned start date in 2012, and in advance of this we would expect there to be further opportunities for local people to learn about the services to be provided."







8 Comments
by Pete, Brislington
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 10:45PM
“Nothing's been mentioned in this story about the Cafe at the Walk-in Centre. That's closing at Christmas. Once that's gone, what other facilities are there on site for patients and visitors?
I understand there's talk about the room being used for "community use", but that could mean anything. Perhaps, as someone has already mentioned, something for the new arrivals in the area?
"All the best for Knowle West"?”
by ivor, bristol
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 7:07PM
“they need to import a few islamic ayslum seekers into the area,the council wouldnt dream of closing the centre then, and the local labour mp may even object then as well”
by Rachel**, Knowle Bristol
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 5:51PM
“The Knowle West Walk In Centre is a service that is used by many people in Knowle and the surrounding areas. Every occasion that I have had to use the centre it has always been awfully busy and has meant that I didn't have to travel to the centre for accidents that were easily sorted by nurses. To transfer it to another location would cause many problems, it is a local resource that really should stay. These boards tend to irritate me as others always seem to portray Knowle as an awful place where no one works and everyone is on 'the dole'!! This isn't the case and I think people should visit Knowle before making assumptions. Just because people earn less of a wage packet than others doesn't mean that they are not entitled to locally based healthcare.”
by Tina, Hengrove
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 4:59PM
“It's discusting how the lower income families always seem to have a rough ride. Poor education, poor jobs and poor lifestyles are not always a choice that people choose for themselves, but they always get the rough deals. Many people depend on services close to their homes. It is a busy place for many outside of the area too. It's a shame to take it away.”
by Dave, South Bristol
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 3:59PM
“The Health Park is a fantastic facility for those living within a mile or so radius of it but unrealistic for those further afield or with mobility problems as there is no bus service to the centre which also includes a GP surgery ¿ this then causes much traffic in small side streets. Whereas the new Hengrove site (on the boarder of Knowle West) will have a direct bus service and cover South Bristol for efficiently.”
by Sydders, Bristol
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 3:35PM
“thought you logged off Spidey?
anyway, it costs less to buy value fruit n veg and a sack of potatoes than a bag of fish and chips”
by Irish, Bristol
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 3:08PM
“Spidyman, if you lived in Knowle West, which I have, you would be glad your life expectancy was reduced by 10 years.
Good points and good appreciation of the problems.”
by Spidyman, Bristol
Wednesday, November 25 2009, 2:42PM
“Life expectancy (in Knowle) is, on average, 10 years less than in other areas. What a shocking statistic. Why? Because people in poorer areas drink and smoke more? Poorer nutrition on a diet of chips & pizza? Both?
How much did this centre cost for a 9 year lifespan, and how much will it's replacement cost? What a pitiful story all round. Far too many questions left unanswered if you ask me (which I admit you didn't).”