Airbus fined £200,000 for Bristol Concorde death fall
Aircraft manufacturing giant Airbus has been fined £200,000 plus £58,000 costs after its failure to ensure health and safety at its Filton based Concorde exhibition cost a Bristol pensioner his life.
Bristol Crown Court was told 71-year-old Horace Livall died when he stepped into a gap at the side of the gantry and fell some seven metres to his death.
-
Airbus UK Ltd and BAC Trading Ltd both admitted a breach of the Health & Safety At Work Act in September 2004.
As well as the Airbus penalty Judge Julian Lambert, who said it was "An accident waiting to happen", fined BAC £10,000 with £1,000 costs.
The former milkman from Southmead suffered serious head and chest injuries and, though he received emergency first aid at the scene, he died in hospital a short time later.
Airbus UK Limited and BAC Trading Limited both admitted a breach of the Health and Safety at Work Act in September 2004.
James Bennett, prosecuting, told the court Airbus, estimated at the end of 2007 to have a turnover in excess of £1.8 billion, took custody of the decommissioned Concorde aircraft from BA in December 2003.
While Airbus organised a visitor centre and access to the aircraft, BAC Trading Limited was a charity, whose volunteers staffed the exhibit for public tours.
Mr Bennett said it was the prosecution's case that attempts to form a working relationship by Airbus and BAC failed, and, in July 2004, Airbus, through its contractors, supplied an unsafe gantry to view the aircraft, with no agreement for checking it or ensuring health and safety.
Mr Bennett said the crux of the matter was that the aircraft was difficult to display safely because, when it was drained of fluids, it was unclear about how it would stand, and it was also deemed to be priceless and therefore shouldn't be damaged.
The court heard that the result was a gantry to give access to the aircraft, which fell short of joining to it, and a temporary wooden plinth had to be constructed to give access, which had no handrails and had gaps each side.
At an inquest into Mr Livall's death held last June, a jury condemned the people responsible for opening Concorde 216 to the public for a series of health and safety failures.
Exhibition organiser Bristol Aero Collection (BAC) and Airbus UK, which owns Filton airfield, were both criticised at the end of the inquest.
After almost four hours of deliberation the jury returned an open verdict yesterday and emphasised three key factors in the tragic events that unfolded that day.
They pointed to a "failure to conduct a thorough risk assessment" after the gantry was built, the lack of written or verbal communication between







Comments
by Chris MAY, Chew Magna
Thursday, January 08 2009, 8:41AM
“Would it be possible to have a copy of the whole of the story? Your website only gives the first of three "key factors" which you say the jury made.”