£600,000 spent on art in Bristol hospitals in two years
ALMOST £600,000 was spent on art to enhance Bristol hospitals in a two-year-period.
Health trusts in the area also paid almost £80,000 on arts consultants to advise them about the way they use art in hospitals during 2008-09 and 2009-10, according to figures obtained by the Evening Post.
-

North Bristol NHS Trust arts programme manager Ruth Sidgwick celebrates the installation of a new sculpture at Frenchay in February
About £145,000 has been put aside by hospitals in north Bristol and the city centre to fund art projects this year.
Almost half of the money due to be spent on art in the coming year will be paid for out of North Bristol NHS Trust's (NBT) budget.
The health trust, which runs Frenchay and Southmead hospitals, plans to spend £92,542 this financial year, with £69,000 coming from the taxpayer.
University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust (UHBristol), which runs Bristol Royal Infirmary will spend £54,325 on art projects this year for the children's hospital and oncology centre but it will all be paid out of charitable funds.
As previously reported in the Evening Post, North Bristol NHS Trust has been criticised for plans to spend £1.4 million on art at the new Southmead Hospital, with the bulk coming from NHS budgets.
Spending from NHS budgets has to be approved by a trust board, which consists of hospital directors and members of the public.
Managers have explained that the artwork will enhance the new buildings for patients and visitors, making stays in hospital more pleasant and aiding recuperation.
In 2008-09, £76,611 was spent by NBT on artwork and £118,498 was spent last year.
NBT also makes money from the art that is displayed in its hospitals, taking a 20-per-cent commission from the sale of art exhibited at its sites.
Last year £1,013 was contributed to arts funding from sales within the hospital and a similar amount is expected next year.
Artwork was funded using £61,184 of charitable funds last year, specifically donated for artwork.
Anaesthetist Dr Fiona McVey has worked at Southmead Hospital since 1994 and believes art helps patients to feel relaxed.
She said: "As a practising clinician, an appropriately pleasant environment improves my interaction with patients and relatives. "Conversely, it is harder to be reassuring to patients when discussing details of their forthcoming anaesthetic in a dingy, unwelcoming place. Appropriate art can humanise a space that may otherwise feel unfamiliar, clinical or intimidating."
The trust that runs the BRI and children's hospital has spent more than £380,000 on art since 2008 and £36,621 on arts consultants.
Even the £20,000 salary for an arts co-ordinator came out of charitable funds.
Arts projects were an important part of the Bristol Heart Institute (BHI) behind the Bristol Royal Infirmary, which opened last May.
UHBristol spent about £200,000 on the project, which includes a glass lifeboat sculpture that hangs in the atrium and works on the ceilings of the lifts used for transporting patients in beds, but every penny was raised by the hospital charity Above and Beyond.
Above and Beyond Charities chief executive Sarah Talbot-Williams said: "We are absolutely above and beyond what the NHS provides. It is about working with hospitals and working out what are the added extras that can provide a positive healing environment.
"The NHS is stretched, they cannot do the added extras.
"We had a tremendous response for the Heart of Bristol appeal and the Care appeal."
Cardiac services matron at the BHI, Graham Brant, was involved in the planning of the building since before it began and has seen the difference the environment has made first hand.
He said: "From our point of view, if you didn't have the artwork the BHI would be very white and very clinical.
"Things like the lifeboat are not only beautiful pieces of art but also act as a signpost to help people find their way around the building.
"I think patients feel they are in a bright, clean 21st-century environment. From a staff point of view, the art increases morale."
Kingswood MP and member of the health select committee, Chris Skidmore, believes taxpayers' money should not be used for artwork in hospital.
He said: "At times of economic difficulty we need to be looking hard at how we spend that money. It should be spent first and foremost on funding key services for patients themselves have better quality healthcare, that does not mean spending money on art."







12 Comments
View all
by Gordon Bennett, Bristol
Tuesday, August 03 2010, 7:40PM
“Samantha Creed, Longwell Green
I just hope you are never laying in a hospital bed suffering terminal cancer simply because to treat it would be too expensive!”
by JC, Bath
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 10:19PM
“WTF is a £36K 'art Consultant'? And a £20K 'Art Co-ordinator'? Is that the person who buys the pictures? So £56K on a couple of dudes to choose a few pictures, nice work if you can get it!”
by s, St Andrews
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 9:45PM
“Why doesn't the NHS make links with UWE and Filton College art courses and exhibit student work? No charge to the NHS, but good free publicity for the students. I am sure the course tutors can be "...art consultants to advise them about the way they use art in hospitals..."”
by Londoner, in the west
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 4:32PM
“Pleasant surroundings help all, there's little doubt about that. Most of these, in hospitals, can be achieved voluntarily. With a bit of thought, 'clinical white' can be replaced by other colours.
This sort of art is not only expensive, but it can cost lives. There have been several cases where potential life-extending treatments have been refused to cancer patients on a cost-basis. They have then had to beg for their lives via the media. Surely, that's not how an organisation, funded by most of us, should operate?
Art-for-life based at Musgrove pk hospital in Taunton - http://www.artforlife.nhs.uk/- costs 60k per year in salaries alone. I think that money could be spent on healthcare, prevention and medical staff.”
by bladerunner, Bristol
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 2:11PM
“Yet more hypocrisy from our local rent-a -quote MP. Perhaps we should ask him to tell us how much public money is spent on decorating parliament, MP's offices, ministry buildings etc. but I suppose that will be somehow different?”
by David, Bristol
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 2:05PM
“What a load of old rubbish this money should be spent on things that we really are in need of in our hospitals,not stupid paintings i think somebody needs to look into this waste of money”
by Samantha Creed, Longwell Green
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 1:54PM
“I like the art, I also consider it money well spent.
I'm sure if it was blank walls you lot would find something to complain about...
It's all from different budgets.”
by derek, Not in Briz
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 12:40PM
“I was a patient in Southmead many years ago and my main comfort while I was recovering were books to read and as I got better to help the nurses taking tea etc to bedridden patients.I couldn`t have given a damn about silly paintings on the walls.The money could have been far better spent on making life easier for the sick.”
by Shh, Under the stairs!
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 11:54AM
“What a horrendous waste of money which should be put to better use - such as staff or equipment, or even building maintenence.
I especially like the 'artwork' in pictrure 1 - a celebration of White Supremacy as 2 'dark' people can be seen supporting a 'light' person!”
by Mike B, Bristol
Wednesday, July 28 2010, 11:07AM
“When I was in Hospital, it was the friendly smiles and pleasant chatter from the nurses that made me fell better, and get better :D
It was not the awful art they had on the walls and corridors :-(
These people that spend OUR MONEY on such things need a good kicking, and should be made to do some proper community work to make their brains get real.”